Virtue Theory and Elitism: from the View of MacIntyre's Practice Concept

孙小玲
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.0257-0289.2009.01.010
2009-01-01
Abstract:Through a careful analysis and evaluation of the elitism charge that targets at one core concept of MacIntyre's virtue theory,namely,practice,we will try in this essay to lay bare both the problematic inherence in this liberalist charge and its presupposition as well as the problematic of MacIntyre's virtue theory,which is partly pinpointed by the said elitism charge.Insofar as this elitism charge is made out of a fairly liberalist anti-elitism perspective which is implicitly shared by MacIntyre himself,it is for MacIntyre not refutable as long as he rejects seeing its discrepancy with the tradition he committed to.Thus,our ultimate aim is to promote a deep reflection on the relation between classical morality and modern moral theory,which MacIntyre failed to do due to his completely negative attitude towards modernity.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?