Abstract:The subject of BCS–Bose–Einstein condensation (BEC) crossover is particularly exciting because of its realization in ultracold atomic Fermi gases and its possible relevance to high temperature superconductors. In this paper we review the body of theoretical work on this subject, which represents a natural extension of the seminal papers by Leggett and by Nozières and Schmitt-Rink (NSR). The former addressed only the ground state, now known as the “BCS-Leggett” wave-function, and the key contributions of the latter pertain to calculations of the superfluid transition temperature Tc. These two papers have given rise to two main and, importantly, distinct, theoretical schools in the BCS–BEC crossover literature. The first of these extends the BCS-Leggett ground state to finite temperature and the second extends the NSR scheme away from Tc both in the superfluid and normal phases. It is now rather widely accepted that these extensions of NSR produce a different ground state than that first introduced by Leggett. This observation provides a central motivation for the present paper which seeks to clarify the distinctions in the two approaches. Our analysis shows how the NSR-based approach views the bosonic contributions more completely but treats the fermions as “quasi-free”. By contrast, the BCS-Leggett based approach treats the fermionic contributions more completely but treats the bosons as “quasi-free”. In a related fashion, the NSR-based schemes approach the crossover between BCS and BEC by starting from the BEC limit and the BCS-Leggett based scheme approaches this crossover by starting from the BCS limit. Ultimately, one would like to combine these two schemes. There are, however, many difficult problems to surmount in any attempt to bridge the gap in the two theory classes. In this paper we review the strengths and weaknesses of both approaches. The flexibility of the BCS-Leggett based approach and its ease of handling make it widely used in T=0 applications, although the NSR-based schemes tend to be widely used at T≠0. To reach a full understanding, it is important in the future to invest effort in investigating in more detail the T=0 aspects of NSR-based theory and at the same time the T≠0 aspects of BCS-Leggett theory.

Thermodynamics and Superfluid Density in BCS-BEC Crossover with and Without Population Imbalance

Finite Temperature Effects in Trapped Fermi Gases with Population Imbalance

Theory of Superfluids with Population Imbalance: Finite Tem perature and BCS-BEC Crossover Effects

Superfluidity and pairing phenomena in ultracold atomic Fermi gases in one-dimensional optical lattices, Part II: Effects of population imbalance

Fermionic Superfluidity: from High T-C Superconductors to Ultracold Fermi Gases

BCS-BEC Crossover in Symmetric Nuclear Matter at Finite Temperature: Pairing Fluctuation and Pseudogap

BCS–BEC Crossover: from High Temperature Superconductors to Ultracold Superfluids

Pair Excitations, Collective Modes, and Gauge Invariance in the Bcs-Bose-Einstein Crossover Scenario

Superfluid Phase Diagrams of Trapped Fermi Gases with Population Imbalance

BCS-BEC Crossover at Finite Temperature in Spin-Orbit-coupled Fermi Gases

BCS-BEC crossover in atomic Fermi gases in quasi-two-dimensional Lieb lattices: Effects of flat band and finite temperature

Superfluidity and pairing phenomena in ultracold atomic Fermi gases in one-dimensional optical lattices, Part I: Balanced case

Specific heat and effects of strong pairing fluctuations in a superfluid Fermi atom gas in the BCS-BEC crossover region

Finite-temperature Behavior of an Interspecies Fermionic Superfluid with Population Imbalance

Comparison of Different Pairing Fluctuation Approaches to BCS–BEC Crossover

Excitation properties and effects of mass imbalance in the BCS-BEC crossover regime of an ultracold Fermi gas

Stability conditions and phase diagrams for two component Fermi gases with population imbalance

Effect Of The Particle-Hole Channel On Bcs-Bose-Einstein Condensation Crossover In Atomic Fermi Gases

Impurity Effects on BCS-BEC Crossover in Ultracold Atomic Fermi Gases

Publisher's Note: Theory of Superfluids with Population Imbalance: Finite-temperature and BCS-BEC Crossover Effects [phys. Rev. B75, 014521 (2007)]

Reentrant Superfluidity And Pair Density Wave In Single-Component Dipolar Fermi Gases