“Power Comparisons for Genotypic Vs. Allelic TDT Methods with >2 Alleles”
D Fallin,T Beaty,KY Liang,WM Chen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/gepi.10192
2002-01-01
Genetic Epidemiology
Abstract:To the Editor: Family-based association methods have become increasingly popular tools for both fine mapping and candidate gene association studies. Of such methods, the transmission disequilibrium test (TDT) has received the most attention [Spielman et al., 1993; Risch and Merikangas, 1996]. This test was originally proposed as an ‘‘allelic’’ test of linkage and association which compares transmitted to nontransmitted alleles in parents of cases in a matched analysis [Spielman et al., 1993]. Several have pointed out that the TDT can also be framed as a genotypic test of linkage and association [Self et al. 1991; Schaid, 1999], similar to the genotype relative risk modeling of Schaid and Sommer [1993], by comparing the case’s transmitted genotype to the set of all possible genotypes for that individual, given the parental genotypes. This ‘‘genotypic’’ TDT allows for assessment of genotype relative risks and modeling of particular risk relationships, while the allelic version must make an implicit assumption of multiplicative effects of alleles. Further, this framework allows analysis of individuals, rather than considering chromosomes as the unit of observation, which provides a natural setting for the inclusion of covariates and tests for possible interaction [Schaid and Sommer, 1993]. Schaid [1999] presented a likelihood framework for the genotypic TDT, allowing likelihood ratio (LR) testing, and showed modeling situations in which this LR test method outperforms the allelic score and LR test versions, using diallelic markers [Schaid and Sommer, 1993]. Specifically, the ‘‘genotypic’’ LR test provided more statistical power across recessive models and for dominant models with frequent risk alleles [Schaid and Sommer, 1993]. Recently, there has been a great deal of interest in haplotype-based association methods, considering the potential increases in statistical power to detect a diseaseassociated variant by considering alleles at several markers across a region