Does Inventory Pooling Improve Customer Service Levels?

Meng Li,Jun Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.orl.2011.12.003

IF: 1.151

2012-01-01

Operations Research Letters

Abstract:We study the risk pooling problem in a two-location inventory system, and analytically demonstrate that pooling improves the Type-I service levels at both locations. We also present an example showing that pooling may reduce the Type-II service levels at both locations.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Demand Pooling in Omnichannel Operations

Ming Hu,Xiaolin Xu,Weili Xue,Yi Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2021.3964

2018-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:Both traditional retailers and e-tailers have been implementing omnichannel strategies such as buy online, pick up at store (BOPS). We build a stylized model to investigate the impact of the BOPS initiative on store operations from an inventory perspective. We consider two segments of customers, namely store-only customers who only make purchases offline and omni-customers who strategically choose between offline and online channels. We show that BOPS may either benefit or hurt the retailer depending on two fundamental system primitives: the store visiting cost and the online waiting cost. If the online waiting cost is relatively low and the store visiting cost is even lower, BOPS can induce omni-customers to migrate from online buying to BOPS, leading to demand pooling at the brick-and-mortar (B&M) store. Such demand pooling provides two benefits for the retailer: it reduces the overstocking cost, and after inventory reoptimization, it results in a higher fill rate at the B&M store, which benefits existing customers and potentially attracts more customers to the store. In contrast, if both store visiting and online waiting costs are relatively high with the latter even higher, introducing BOPS can result in demand depooling as a result of the migration of the omni-customers from offline purchasing to BOPS. This leads to a lower fill rate after inventory reoptimization, likely the result of a lower profit margin under BOPS, which turns away store-only customers and hurts the retailer. This paper was accepted by Charles Corbett, operations management.
Managing Inventory for a Multidivisional Firm with Cash Pooling.

Kevin Shang,Jianan Wang,Yi Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1561/0200000064

2017-01-01

Foundations and Trends in Technology, Information and Operations Management

Abstract:We consider a multi-divisional firm in which each division replenishes its inventory and the headquarter coordinates the cash flow through a master account over a finite horizon. The demands of the divisions are stochastic and may be correlated. The objective is to find an optimal joint inventory replenishment and cash retention policy which maximizes the firmâ€™s working capital. We show that this problem is equivalent to minimizing the total system cost. Due to curse of dimensionality, the optimal policy is difficult to obtain. Nevertheless, we characterize the properties of the optimal policy and develop a simple heuristic that possesses these properties. A numerical study shows that the heuristic is near-optimal. We explore managerial insights through the heuristic. Among others, we find that the value of cash pooling is most significant when the demands of the divisions are negatively correlated.
Risk Pooling Strategy in a Multi-Echelon Supply Chain with Price-Sensitive Demand.

Yue Dai,Shu-Cherng Fang,Xiaoli Ling,Henry L. W. Nuttle

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00186-007-0203-8

2008-01-01

Mathematical Methods of Operations Research

Abstract:This paper studies a nonstationary inventory and pricing problem. We consider a two-echelon supply chain with one supplier and two retailers, in which the supplier carries all inventory to supply the retailers. Both the reserved and pooled inventory systems are analyzed. Results with normally distributed demands are compared. Assuming the random demand at each retailer is price-sensitive, we further consider the cases when the retailers have and do not have service level requirements. We start with analyzing inventory and pricing strategies for the supplier in a one-period scenario. Then we extend our analysis to both the backlogging and lost-sale scenarios in an infinite planning horizon.
Pooled Versus Reserved Inventory Policies in a Two-Echelon Supply Chain

Xiaoli Ling,Shu-Cherng Fang,Henry L. W. Nuttle,Xiuli Chao

2005-01-01

Abstract:We consider a two-echelon supply chain with two retailers and one supplier. The retailers are supplied by the supplier who makes all the decisions and bears all the inventory risk. Throughout this paper, we consider two different inventory systems: a reserved inventory system and a pooled inventory system. With the reserved inventory system, the supplier keeps separate inventories for each retailer. In contrast, the pooled inventory is shared by the two retailers and the supplier makes the inventory decision based on the joint demand. Under different scenarios such as whether wholesale price is a decision variable, we study and analyze the supplier's decisions in the reserved and the pooled inventory systems. In addition, we compare the profit of the supplier and retailers in the two different systems under normally distributed demands.
Performance Bounds and Asymptotic Optimality of Modified (r, Q) Policies for Stochastic Distribution Inventory Systems

Han Zhu,Frank Chen,Ming Hu,Yi Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2921743

2017-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:We study a continuous-review, two-echelon inventory system with one central warehouse, multiple local facilities, and each facility facing random demand. Local facilities replenish their stock from the central warehouse (or distribution center), which in turn places orders at an outside supplier with an ample supply. Inventory replenishment at each location incurs a fixed-plus-variable cost for each shipment. The optimal policy remains unknown, and even if it exists, such a policy must be extremely complicated. Instead, we evaluate a class of easy-to-implement heuristics, called modified echelon (r, Q) policies. The parameters for such a heuristic are obtained by solving a set of independent single-stage systems. We show that the proposed policy is asymptotically optimal, as pairs of system primitives, such as the ratios of the fixed cost of the central facility to those of the local facilities, are scaled up. We also show that as the number of retailers grows, the performance bound of the heuristic converges to a primitive-dependent constant.
Risk Pooling, Supply Chain Hierarchy, and Analysts’ Forecasts

Nan Hu,Jian-Yu (Fisher) Ke,Ling Liu,Yue Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/poms.12904

IF: 4.638

2019-01-01

Production and Operations Management

Abstract:We investigate whether a firm's risk pooling affects its analysts’ forecasts, specifically in terms of forecast accuracy and their use of public vs. private information, and how risk pooling interacts with a firm's position in the supply chain to affect analysts’ forecasts. We use a social network analysis method to operationalize risk pooling and supply chain hierarchy, and find that risk pooling significantly reduces analysts’ forecast errors and increases (decreases) their use of public (private) information. We also find that the positive (negative) relationships between risk pooling and analyst forecast accuracy and analysts’ use of public (private) information are more pronounced upstream than downstream in a supply chain.
A Heterogeneous Reliable Location Model with Risk Pooling under Supply Disruptions

Ying Zhang,Lawrence V. Snyder,Mingyao Qi,Lixin Miao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trb.2015.11.009

2016-01-01

Abstract:This paper investigates a facility location model that considers the disruptions of facilities and the cost savings from the inventory risk-pooling effect and economies of scale. Facilities may have heterogeneous disruption probabilities. When a facility fails, its customers may be reassigned to other surviving ones to hedge against lost-sales costs. We first develop both an exact and an approximate expression for the nonlinear inventory cost, and then formulate the problem as a nonlinear integer programming model. The objective is to minimize the expected total cost across all possible facility failure scenarios. To solve this problem, we design two methods, an exact approach using special ordered sets of type two (SOS2) and a heuristic based on Lagrangian relaxation. We test the model and algorithms on data sets with up to 150 nodes. Computational results show that the proposed algorithms can solve the problem efficiently in reasonable time. Managerial insights on the optimal facility deployment, customer assignments and inventory control strategies are also drawn. (C) 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
On-demand ride-hailing platforms with heterogeneous quality-sensitive customers: Dedicated system or pooling system?

Yuanguang Zhong,Yibo Lan,Zhi Chen,Jiazi Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trb.2023.04.003

2023-05-20

Abstract:We examine how an on-demand ride-hailing platform chooses between the dedicated system and the pooling system when facing heterogeneous customers and drivers. In the dedicated system, there are two independent queues where quality-sensitive and quality-insensitive customers can be matched with drivers of low- or high-quality service, respectively; while in the pooling system, both types of customers are randomly matched with all drivers without distinguishing the service quality. We characterize the heterogeneity of customers and drivers, and we analyze the platform's optimal pricing and wage decisions in the two systems, respectively. Comparing the two systems, we find that when the driver's basic opportunity cost is not quite large and the difference in opportunity cost between two types of drivers is relatively small, the pooling system can achieve a win-win-win outcome for all participants ( i.e. , customers, drivers, and the platform). Furthermore, a high level of customers' sensitivity to service quality can increase the platform profit in the dedicated system but has no impact on the pooling system. However, when the level of customers' sensitivity to service quality is within a certain range (which is relatively small), quality-sensitive customers may pay a higher price to join the pooling system compared with the case in the dedicated system.

transportation,transportation science & technology,engineering, civil,operations research & management science,economics
A Copula Approach to Inventory Pooling Problems with Newsvendor Products

Burcu Aydın,Kemal Guler,Enis Kayış

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1202.3180

2012-02-15

Abstract:This study focuses on the inventory pooling problem under the newsvendor framework. The specific focus is the change in inventory levels when product inventories are pooled. We provide analytical conditions under which an increase (or decrease) in the total inventory levels should be expected. We introduce the copula framework to model a wide range of dependence structures between pooled demands, and provide a numerical study that gives valuable insights into the effect of marginal demand distributions and dependence structure on the effect of pooling to inventory levels.

Optimization and Control
Inventory rationing policy and backup supply with two classes of customers

Mingwu Liu,Xiaomei Wei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0214386

IF: 3.7

2019-04-12

PLoS ONE

Abstract:In this paper, we consider joint decisions on inventory rationing and replenishment from a regular supplier or a backup supplier with two classes of customers. When the on-hand inventory falls below a certain critical level, an inventory rationing policy is implemented to reject lower priority customers. We investigated the potential use of a backup supplier as a response to inventory rationing policy. First, we establish an inventory level transition equilibrium equation for the steady-state inventory level probability distributions and derive analytical steady-state performance indicators. Next, the inventory cost function and the nonlinear optimization model are characterized. We use real-coded genetic algorithm (RCGA) to search for the optimal joint decisions. Finally, the proposed algorithm and the joint decisions are investigated with different inventory service polices through numerical experiments. The results show that the inventory rationing policy (IRP) is superior to the traditional priority service policy (CPSP) and the common first-come-first service policy (FCFSP). The backup supply can reduce inventory costs with high arrival intensity.
Supplement to 'A Simple Heuristic Policy for Stochastic Distribution Inventory Systems with Fixed Shipment Costs'

Han Zhu,Frank Y. Chen,Ming Hu,Yi Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3606084

2020-01-01

Abstract:As a supplement to Zhu et al. (2020), this document consists of five parts. First, it provides technical proofs of some theoretical results in Zhu et al. (2020). Second, it introduces some preliminary results on stochastic distribution systems with fixed shipment costs. Third, it provides some examples and illustrations on the modified echelon (r,Q) policies (and some related concepts) studied in Zhu et al. (2020). Fourth, it presents some explicit performance bounds that depends on system primitives for the modified echelon (r,Q) policies in stochastic distribution systems. Finally, extensive numerical experiments are conducted to test the effectiveness of the modified echelon (r,Q) policies. Specifically, the numerical studies show that the modified echelon (r,Q) policies perform well with an average gap of about 5% above the cost lower bound, 2) outperform the echelon-stock (r, Q) policy used in Chen and Zheng (1997), and 3) have robust performances with respect to the allocation rule at the warehouse.
Value of Cargo Pooling in On-Demand Intra-City Freight Logistics

Zhengtao Lei,Hai Jiang,Shaosheng Cao,Lisheng Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/03611981231191517

IF: 1.7

2023-01-01

Transportation Research Record

Abstract:On-demand intra-city freight logistics (ICFL) has recently emerged as a new freight service, where shippers can submit their shipping requests using smartphones and be matched to drivers in real time based on their locations and drivers' availability. A major challenge faced by on-demand ICFL platforms is the shortage of vehicles during peak demand periods. Cargo pooling, the cargo version of carpooling, offers as a promising way to increase supply: cargoes heading in the same direction would share the cargo compartment of the same vehicle and be serviced simultaneously, which is achieved by careful sequencing of the pickup and delivery locations of the cargoes. We investigate models for cargo pooling for on-demand ICFL and quantify its benefit, which is new to the literature. The major difference between existing studies on ICFL and ours is that we no longer assume that demands are known beforehand. Instead, the demands arrive gradually throughout the day and we need to periodically match requests to drivers and re-optimize vehicle routes. We formulate the matching problem as a dynamic pickup and delivery problem with three-dimensional loading and time window constraints. To solve this model, we develop an algorithm based on large neighborhood search and tree search. The algorithm is tested with real freight data in a city in the Yangtze River Delta. Results show that the algorithm can reduce the total cost by 21.4% and reduce the total vehicle miles traveled by 36.0%.
An inventory sharing and allocation method for a multi-location service parts logistics network with time-based service levels

Erhan Kutanoglu,Mohit Mahajan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejor.2007.12.032

IF: 6.4

2009-05-01

European Journal of Operational Research

Abstract:We consider a model to allocate stock levels at warehouses in a service parts logistics network. The network is a two-echelon distribution system with one central warehouse with infinite capacity and a number of local warehouses, each facing Poisson demands from geographically dispersed customers. Each local warehouse uses a potentially different base stock policy. The warehouses are collectively required to satisfy time-based service targets: Certain percentages of overall demand need to be satisfied from facilities within specified time windows. These service levels not only depend on the distance between customers and the warehouses, but also depend on the part availabilities at the warehouses. Moreover, the warehouses share their inventory as a way to increase achieved service levels, i.e., when a local warehouse is out of stock, demand is satisfied with an emergency shipment from another close-by warehouse. Observing that the problem of finding minimum-cost stock levels is an integer non-linear program, we develop an implicit enumeration-based method which adapts an existing inventory sharing model from the literature, prioritizes the warehouses for emergency shipments, and makes use of a lower bound. The results show that the proposed inventory sharing strategy results in considerable cost reduction when compared to the no-sharing case and the method is quite efficient for the considered test problems.

operations research & management science
Research on location model of risk pooling with compensation policy

Fei Wang,Tao Jia,Xinbu Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/ICLSIM.2010.5461184

2010-01-01

Abstract:We summarized recent research aimed at expanding the context of facility location decisions to incorporate additional features of a supply chain including variable construction cost, inventory management, transportation cost, etc. Authors expended location model of risk pooling with variable construction cost (LMRPVCC) to construct location model of risking pool with variable construction cost with compensation policy. In a buyer market, logistics corporations may apply compensation policy in order to hold more customers by giving a discount transportation charge. Authors build a square nonlinear 0-1 integer-programming model and use particle swarm optimization algorithm to find suboptimum solutions. The numerical examples are given separately along with the models to evaluate the effectiveness of the model. According to the computational results, we can draw these conclusions: transport costs factor Ã is positively related with the objective function value. Compensation cost factor W is positively related with the objective function value. Distribution radius Dr is negatively related with the objective function value.
Building Supply Chain Resilience Through Virtual Stockpile Pooling

Fang Liu,Jing-Sheng Song,Jordan D. Tong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/poms.12573

IF: 4.638

2016-01-01

Production and Operations Management

Abstract:Stockpiling inventory is an essential strategy for building supply chain resilience. It enables firms to continue operating while finding a solution to an unexpected event that causes a supply disruption or demand surge. While extremely valuable when actually deployed, stockpiles incur large holding costs and usually provide no benefits until such a time. To help to reduce this cost, this study presents a new approach for managing stockpiles. We show that if leveraged intelligently, stockpiles can also help an organization better meet its own regular demand by enabling a type of virtual pooling we call virtual stockpile pooling (VSP). The idea of VSP is to first integrate the stockpile into several locations’ regular inventory buffers and then dynamically reallocate the stockpile among these locations in reaction to the demand realizations to achieve a kind of virtual transshipment. To study how to execute VSP and determine when it can provide the most value, we formulate a stylized multi‐location stochastic inventory model and solve for the optimal stockpile allocation and inventory order policies. We show that VSP can provide significant cost savings: in some cases nearly the full holding cost of the stockpile (i.e., VSP effectively maintains the stockpile for free), in other cases nearly the savings of traditional physical inventory pooling. Last, our results prescribe implementing VSP with many locations for large stockpiles, but only a few locations for small stockpiles.
Effects of Inventory Policy on Supply Chain Performance: A Simulation Study of Critical Decision Parameters

R. S. M. Lau,Jinxing Xie,Xiande Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cie.2008.02.002

IF: 7.18

2008-01-01

Computers & Industrial Engineering

Abstract:This paper investigates the effects of information sharing and early order commitment on the performance of four inventory policies used by retailers in a supply chain of one capacitated supplier and four retailers. Model parameters and operating conditions are emulated from a local business supplying a standard product to its retailers. Through computer simulation and subsequent analyses, we found that the inventory policy used by the retailers, information sharing, and early order commitment can significantly influence the performance of the supply chain. Out of the four inventory policies examined, the economic order quantity rule is found to be the best for the retailers and the entire supply chain, but periodic order quantity and Silver–Meal provide the best performance for the supplier. The sharing of future order plans by the retailer and the supplier is also shown to be the most effective way for reducing the supplier’s cost and improving its service level; however, the magnitude of these benefits achieved is less for the retailers. In addition, early order commitment by the retailers is found to be beneficial to the supplier and retailers in reducing their total cost.
Joint Inventory Control and Pricing in a Service-Inventory System

Ata Jalili Marand,Hongyan Li,Anders Thorstenson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpe.2017.07.008

IF: 11.251

2019-01-01

International Journal of Production Economics

Abstract:This study addresses joint inventory control and pricing decisions for a service-inventory system. In such a system both an on-hand inventory item and a positive service time are required to fulfill customer demands. The service-inventory system also captures main features of the classical inventory systems with a positive processing time, e.g., make-to-order systems. In this study the service-inventory system is modeled as an M/M/1 queue in which the customer arrival rate is price dependent. The inventory of an individual item is continuously reviewed under an (r, Q) policy. The replenishment lead times of the inventory are exponentially distributed. Furthermore, customers arriving during stock-out periods are lost. The stochastic customer inter-arrival times, service times, and inventory replenishment lead times cause the high complexity of the problem and the difficulty in solving it. The aim of this study is to formulate the problem and solve it to optimality. We make three main contributions: (1) We integrate inventory control and pricing in the service-inventory system. The problem is formulated and analyzed as a fractional programming problem, and structural properties are explored for the model. (2) Two solution algorithms are proposed. The first one provides optimal solutions, while the second one is more efficient. (3) The impact of the integrated inventory control and pricing decisions on the overall system performance is investigated. We compare the solutions of the models both with and without fill-rate and service-reliability constraints and report the main interesting managerial insights.
Dynamic Pooling of Make-To-Stock and Make-To-Order Operations

Zhe George Zhang,Ilhyung Kim,Mark Springer,Gangshu (George) Cai,Yugang Yu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpe.2013.01.012

IF: 11.251

2013-01-01

International Journal of Production Economics

Abstract:It has become increasingly common for companies to offer make-to-stock (MTS) and make-to-order (MTO) versions of the same product through different sales channels. To satisfy these two distinct demand streams, one strategy is to produce both the MTS and MTO items in a single “hybrid” facility partially comprised of flexible servers or machines. We develop a multi-server queueing model of this system, where a subset of the servers or machines is dynamically switched between MTS and MTO production via a congestion-based switching policy. We develop analytical formulae for quantifying all major performance measures of the system. We also present a search procedure to find the capacity and inventory control parameters which minimize the total costs of the system while satisfying the customer service constraints. Numerical results are used to illustrate the general behavior of the dynamic hybrid system and to compare its performance to that of a more conventional static hybrid facility with dedicated MTS and MTO servers. For high levels of traffic intensity, the dynamic system is shown to provide superior customer service for both sales channels with lower finished goods inventory levels.
Capacity reservation for time-sensitive service providers: An application in seaport management.

L. Jeff Hong,Xiaowei Xu,Sheng Hao Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejor.2015.03.027

IF: 6.4

2015-01-01

European Journal of Operational Research

Abstract:•We model a facility provider that offers its facility to two service providers.•We examine the tradeoffs between capacity pooling and reservation strategies.•All parties optimal strategy choice depends on the ratio of demand loss rates.•The facility provider prefers the pooling strategy when the above ratio is high.•The service provider with a small demand loss rate prefers the pooling strategy.
Optimal data pooling for shared learning in maintenance operations

Collin Drent,Melvin Drent,Geert-Jan van Houtum

2023-11-07

Abstract:We study optimal data pooling for shared learning in two common maintenance operations: condition-based maintenance and spare parts management. We consider a set of systems subject to Poisson input -- the degradation or demand process -- that are coupled through an a-priori unknown rate. Decision problems involving these systems are high-dimensional Markov decision processes (MDPs) and hence notoriously difficult to solve. We present a decomposition result that reduces such an MDP to two-dimensional MDPs, enabling structural analyses and computations. Leveraging this decomposition, we (i) demonstrate that pooling data can lead to significant cost reductions compared to not pooling, and (ii) show that the optimal policy for the condition-based maintenance problem is a control limit policy, while for the spare parts management problem, it is an order-up-to level policy, both dependent on the pooled data.

Machine Learning,Probability

Does Inventory Pooling Improve Customer Service Levels?

Demand Pooling in Omnichannel Operations

Managing Inventory for a Multidivisional Firm with Cash Pooling.

Risk Pooling Strategy in a Multi-Echelon Supply Chain with Price-Sensitive Demand.

Pooled Versus Reserved Inventory Policies in a Two-Echelon Supply Chain

Performance Bounds and Asymptotic Optimality of Modified (r, Q) Policies for Stochastic Distribution Inventory Systems

Risk Pooling, Supply Chain Hierarchy, and Analysts’ Forecasts

A Heterogeneous Reliable Location Model with Risk Pooling under Supply Disruptions

On-demand ride-hailing platforms with heterogeneous quality-sensitive customers: Dedicated system or pooling system?

A Copula Approach to Inventory Pooling Problems with Newsvendor Products

Inventory rationing policy and backup supply with two classes of customers

Supplement to 'A Simple Heuristic Policy for Stochastic Distribution Inventory Systems with Fixed Shipment Costs'

Value of Cargo Pooling in On-Demand Intra-City Freight Logistics

An inventory sharing and allocation method for a multi-location service parts logistics network with time-based service levels

Research on location model of risk pooling with compensation policy

Building Supply Chain Resilience Through Virtual Stockpile Pooling

Effects of Inventory Policy on Supply Chain Performance: A Simulation Study of Critical Decision Parameters

Joint Inventory Control and Pricing in a Service-Inventory System

Dynamic Pooling of Make-To-Stock and Make-To-Order Operations

Capacity reservation for time-sensitive service providers: An application in seaport management.

Optimal data pooling for shared learning in maintenance operations