Reduction of solubility,bioavailability,and bioaccessibility of heavy metals in polluted soil by mineral amendments
MA Wan-zhu,WANG Hao,ZHANG Ming-kui
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3785/j.issn.1008-9209.2012.02.211
2012-01-01
Abstract:Heavy metal accumulation in the topsoil because traffic,industrial wastes and atmospheric deposition by sedimentation,impaction and interception is well documented.High concentrations of different heavy metals in soil may cause long-term risks to ecosystem and humans.Metals can be mobilized in soil and taken up by edible plants or transported through drainage waters.They can have a direct influence on human health,as they can be transferred into the human body by different pathways,e.g.inhalation of dust or contaminated suspended particles,soil ingestion,and dermal absorption by direct contact.Plant availability,bioaccessibility and solubility of metals in soil are related with these different pathways.Some techniques should be developed to achieve an enduring immobilization or insolubilization of metals in soil,especially when the pollution degree is not extremely high.Many researchers have reported a significant decrease of metal availability in plants when amendments are added to polluted soils.However,little effort has been reported in the literature to decrease metal bioaccessibility and solubility.Therefore,this study has the objective to evaluate the effects of several inexpensive,common mineral amendments on the potential solubility,plant availability,and bioaccessibility of the most environmentally important metals in soils.Six mineral amendment effects as potential immobilizers of heavy metals in two soils(acidic soil and calcareous soil) were studied by monitoring metal availability.The EDTA extraction,simple bioaccessibility extraction test(SBET) and CaCl 2 extraction were applied to measure the plant availability,bioaccessibility and solubility of heavy metals in the soils,respectively.The amendments were agricultural limestone,rock phosphate,palygorskite,calcium magnesium phosphate(Ca-Mg-P) fertilizer,zeolite,and Fe(OH) 3,which were applied to the soils at rate of 50g / kg,respectively.Adsorption / desorption experiments of metals by isolated amendments showed that all amendments caused a strong retention of metals from solutions,with negligible release by dilution.The proportions of heavy metals adsorbed in six mineral materials were higher than 97.2%,and the proportions of heavy metals remained in the mineral materials were higher than 96.8%after the first and second desorption steps of the experiments of adsorption / desorption of metals in solution.Chemical fractions of Cd,Cu,Pb,and Zn in the soils were affected by application of the mineral materials.Treatments of the mineral materials reduced exchangeable metals in the soils.There were chemical transformations of heavy metal fractions in the soils from exchangeable fractions to carbonate-bound,oxide-bound,and residual fractions when the mineral materials were applied,and the transformation varied with different types of amendments.The reduction effects of metal availability induced by amendment application decreased in the order of solubility > plant availability> bioaccessibility.The effects in acidic soil were greater than those in the calcareous soil.In general,Ca-MgP fertilizer,palygorskite or rock phosphate treatments were most suitable for decreasing water soluble heavy metals in the polluted soils.The most suitable mineral materials in decreasing plant availability were Ca-Mg-P fertilizer for Cd,palygorskite for Cu,Ca-Mg-P fertilizer or palygorskite for Zn,and agricultural limestone,rock phosphate or palygorskite for Pb.However,these amendments were scarcely efficient in reducing bioaccessibility of the metals,and the metals extracted by SBET in all six amendment treatments were very similar to the control treatment.Only Fe(OH) 3,zeolite and Ca-Mg-P fertilizer had slight effects in reducing bioaccessibility of heavy metals of the soils.It is concluded that all six tested mineral amendments are effective to stabilize soluble metal fraction in the soils polluted with Cd,Cu,Pb,and Zn.These minerals are able to decrease water solubility and plant availability of the metals in the soils.However,plant availability and bioaccessibility are not synonymous.These amendments are often used as metal immobilizers and are of limited efficiency for decreasing bioaccessibility of the metals in the soils.Therefore other techniques are needed for controlling and eventually decreasing metal bioaccessibility in the soils.