Efficacy of minimally invasive electrocoagulation and conventional ligation add tripping to treat lower limb varicose veins of Chinese people : A Meta-analysis

CHEN Lei,GAO Jian-guo,ZHANG Qing-yun,YANG Zhi,GUO Feng-ling,LIU Yan-chun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3877/cma.j.issn.1674-0785.2013.20.054

2013-01-01

Abstract:Objective To provide reliable evidence to guide clinical practice by evaluating the efficacy of the treatment of minimally invasive electrocoagulation and ligation add tripping which are used to treat lower limb varicose veins of Chinese people comprehensively and objectively. Methods We searched all clinical controlled trials in the Wanfang Database, CNKI and Weipu Database from those database built to 2012 about electrocoagulation and ligation add tripping to treat lower limb varicose veins, and those selected studies are used to make a meta-analysis using Rev.Man5.0. Results Eight studies including a total of 948 cases(electrocoagulation: 549; ligation add tripping: 435) were included in the study. Operation time[OR-41.95,95% CI(-62.18,-21.72)], hospitalization time[OR-6.87,95% CI(-9.14,-4.16)] and rate of postoperative complications[OR 0.38,95% CI(0.17,0.84)] were significantly reduced in patients with lower limb varicose veins who were underwent electrocoagulation ligation add tripping(P<0.05); while the recurrence rate[OR 0.26,95% CI(0.06,1.12)] has no difference between electrocoagulation and ligation add tripping(P>0.05). Conclusion At present, minimally invasive electrocoagulation is an ideal alternative to treat lower limb varicose veins of Chinese people, but there is no available evidence to indicate that minimally invasive electrocoagulation can completely replace ligation add tripping.