Diagnostic Value of Bedside Echocardiography with Simple A-F Mnemonic Within 5 Minutes by Beginners in Patients with Acute Chest Pain
Yang Liming,Zhao Bowen,Hong Yucai,Wang Bei,Peng Xiaohui,Li Qiang,Li Xiuru,Yu Cong,Han Ying
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.1671-0282.2019.01.017
2019-01-01
Abstract:Objective To evaluate the diagnostic value of A-F mnemonic performed by sonographers with limited experience in patients with acute chest pain. Methods This was a prospective observational study. Bedside cardiac ultrasound for patients with chest pain was performed by six sonographers with limited experience using A-F mnemonic, evaluating indexes including aortic dissection(A), both ventricles (B), regional wall motion abnormality (RWMA), left ventricular ejection fraction (LVEF) ≤ 50％ (C ,contractility), dimensions (D), pleural and pericardial effusion (E) and further abnormalities (F). Afterwards, experienced cardiac sonographers performed the same examinations, and the difference in the time of ultrasound examination was calculated. The diagnosis of experienced sonographers were referred as the control group, and kappa test was applied to analyze the sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value and negative predictive value. Results There were 245 cases eligible for study, and 20 cases were excluded. Finally 225 cases of acute chest pain were included in the analysis, containing 158 fatal chest pain and 67 low-risk chest pain. The experienced sonographers diagnosed 20 cases of ascending aortic dissection, 5 cases of right ventricular dilatation, 72 cases of RWMA, 12 cases of LVEF ≤ 50％, 45 cases of left ventricular dilatation, 6 cases of hydropericardium, and 6 cases of other abnormalities. The consistency between beginners and experienced sonographers were as follows:completely same (hydropericardium, Kappa=1.000), highly consistent (ascending aortic dissection, Kappa=0.853, right ventricular dilatation, Kappa=0.931, and other abnormalities, Kappa=0.829), moderately consistent (RWMA, Kappa=0.768, LVEF ≤ 50％, Kappa=0.713 and left ventricular dilatation, Kappa=0.766). The sensitivity and negative predictive value of RWMA and LVEF ≤ 50％ and the positive predictive value of left ventricular dilatation in the beginner sonographers were lower than those in the experienced sonographers. Conclusions A-F mnemonic was a simple and practical way for the beginner sonographers to perform bedside cardiac ultrasound. It was of significant value in making correct diagnosis of most acute chest pain patients and providing quick and reliable information for clinicians.