Abstract:Purpose The Chinese fund market has witnessed significant developments in recent years. However, although there has been a range of studies assessing fund performance in developed industries, the rapidly developing fund industry in China has received very little attention. This study aims to examine the performance of open-end securities investment funds investing in Chinese domestic equity during the period May 2003 to September 2020. Specifically, applying a non-parametric bootstrap methodology from the literature on fund performance, the authors investigate the role of skill versus luck in this rapidly evolving investment funds industry. Design/methodology/approach This study evaluates the performance of Chinese equity securities investment funds from 2003–2020 using a bootstrap methodology to distinguish skill from luck in performance. The authors consider unconditional and conditional performance models. Findings The bootstrap methodology incorporates non-normality in the idiosyncratic risk of fund returns, which is a major drawback in “conventional” performance statistics. The evidence does not support the existence of “genuine” skilled fund managers. In addition, it indicates that poor performance is mainly attributable to bad stock picking skills. Practical implications The authors find that the top-ranked funds with positive abnormal performance are attributed to “good luck” not “good skill” while the negative abnormal performance of bottom funds is mainly due to “bad skill.” Therefore, sensible advice for most Chinese equity investors would be against trying to “pick winners funds” among Chinese securities investment funds but it would be recommended to avoid holding “losers.” At the present time, investors should consider other types of funds, such as index/tracker funds with lower transactions. In addition, less risk-averse investors may consider Chinese hedge funds [Zhao (2012)] or exchange-traded fund [Han (2012)]. Originality/value The paper makes several contributions to the literature. First, the authors examine a wide range (over 50) of risk-adjusted performance models, which account for both unconditional and conditional risk factors. The authors also control for the profitability and investment risks in Fama and French (2015). Second, the authors select the “best-fit” model across all risk-adjusted models examined and a single “best-fit” model from each of the three classes. Therefore, the bootstrap analysis, which is mainly based on the selected best-fit models, is more precise and robust. Third, the authors reduce the possibility that findings may be sample-period specific or may be a survivor (upward) biased. Fourth, the authors consider further analysis based on sub-periods and compare fund performance in different market conditions to provide more implications to investors and practitioners. Fifth, the authors carry out extensive robustness checks and show that the findings are robust in relation to different minimum fund histories and serial correlation and heteroscedasticity adjustments. Sixth, the authors use higher frequency weekly data to improve statistical estimation.

An Empirical Analysis on the Redemption Puzzle of Open-end Funds in China

An analysis on the effect of private placement by Chinese listed companies

Empirical Study of the Puzzle of Chinese Closed Fund

An Empirical Investigation on Influence Factor of the Open-end Fund Investor Liquidity Demand

The Study of the Close - end Fund Discount Phenomenon in China

Fund Returns and Net Redemptions under Incomplete Information in China

An Empirical Analysis of the Volatility in the Open-End Fund Market: Evidence from China

The Financial Services Industry,“the Survival of the Fittest”or “Inferior Jig”?——To Open-end Fund as An Example

An Empirical Analysis of Influential Factors of China's Capital Allocation Efficiency

Market Structure-Conduct-Performance of Investment Fund Industry in China: an Empirical Analysis Based on Data from 1999 to 2004

Asset Pricing, Jump Risk, and China's B-share Discount Puzzle

Discount Puzzle Of Closed-End Mutual Funds: A Case Of Bangladesh

An Empirical Study on Institutional Industry Herding in China

Marketing expenses and fund asset flows:Evidence from the Chinese open-end fund market

The H-A Price Discount and Its Determinants

Investigation of Fund Managers' Risk-taking Behavior Motivated by Fund Tournament

Chinese securities investment funds: the role of luck in performance

The Test of Kendall's Concordance Coefficient on Ranking Stability of the Open-end Funds' Performances in China

Fund Investors’ Behavior and Rationality

Gambling preferences and fund company ownership: Evidence from China

A Reliable Performance Measure to Differentiate China's Actively Managed Open-End Equity Mutual Funds