The effect of error coefficient matrices and correlation criteria on dic computation errors
Hengrui Cui,Zhoumo Zeng,Jian Li,Hui Zhang,Fenglong Yang,Shili Chen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.optlaseng.2023.107954
IF: 5.666
2023-12-08
Optics and Lasers in Engineering
Abstract:The error estimation formula is one of the key points in DIC research. However, most of the correlation criterion used in the research of DIC error is SSD instead of the most commonly used ZNSSD. And the existing error estimation formulas are very complicated, which is not conducive to analyse the relationship between interpolation algorithm, gradient calculation method, image spectrum and error. Therefore, there is a need to derive the error formulae applicable to all SSD class correlation criteria and to find the intermediate variables between the interpolation algorithm, gradient algorithm, image spectrum and error based on the general formulae to facilitate the analysis. This work derives the interpolation error generalization and random error generalization for DIC using SSD class correlation criterion, by using the frequency domain based approach. The Error Coefficient Matrix (ECM) is proposed in order to carry out the analysis of the impact on the computational error of the DIC. The DIC methods using SSD class correlation criterion yield almost identical results and are not limited to the expectation or variance of the error. The low-frequency portion of the EMC has a greater influence on the error than high-frequency portion. Conversely, the high-frequency portion of the image spectrum has a greater influence on the error. Among the commonly used interpolation and gradient algorithms discussed in this work, the smallest RMSE are found in the B-spline and Centre difference algorithms, which are 11% and 83% of the maximum, respectively. The findings of this work help to generalise the existing SSD-based findings to ZNSSD, such as optimal subset size, optimal speckle radius, etc. In addition, the best combination of algorithms used in DIC operations is the combination of B-splines and Centre difference operators.
optics