Comparison of Open and Laparoscopic Techniques for Tension-free Hernia Repair for Elderly Patients with Inguinal Hernia
Liu Chen,Zhang Nengwei,Lu Yiping
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1009-6604.2011.05.007
2011-01-01
Abstract:Objective Tto compare the efficacy of open surgery with laparoscopy for tension-free hernia repair in elderly patients suffering from inguinal hernia. Methods Between January 2006 and January 2010,136 elderly patients diagnosed with inguinal hernia underwent open tension-free mesh-plug and patch(open group,n=72) or total extraperitoneal hernioplasty(TEP group,n=64).We collected and compared the clinical data between the two groups.ResultsCompared to TEP group,the open group showed significantly shorter operation time,lower hospital cost,higher pain score in 24 hours and 1 week,and longer hospital stay [(65.0±18.1) min vs.(78.1±12.6) min,t=4.742,P=0.000;(4960.2±1033.3) RMB vs.(6998.0±1632.2) RMB,t=8.796,P=0.000;Z=-7.144,P=0.000 and Z=-6.408,P=0.000;(4.9 ±2.4)d vs.(3.6±1.5) d,t=-3.733,P=0.000].No severe complications were found in the patients.The open group were followed up for 8 to 46 months with a mean of 15 months(>24 months in 11 cases);and the TEP group was followed up for 4 to 35 months with a mean of 14 months(>24 months in 9 cases).None of the patients had recurrence during the period. Conclusions Both open surgery and TEP are effective for elderly patients with inguinal hernia.TEP can be the first choice,especially for bilateral inguinal hernia,for it's less pain and quicker recovery.Open surgery for tension-free hernia repair is less expensive,and easier to perform,and thus is especially suitable for patients with cardiopulmonary diseases that cannot tolerate general anesthesia and CO2 pneumoperitoneum.