Explicit and Implicit Self-Enhancement As Functions of Interpersonal Contexts
LIU Xiao-Cen,SANG Biao,DOU Dong-Hui
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3724/sp.j.1041.2011.01293
2011-01-01
Abstract:The past two decades have seen a considerable research progress on self-enhancement which represents a preeminent self-motive defined as the tendency to hold overly positive self-evaluations.Despite this research,little is known about the potential cultural impact on self-enhancement.More specifically,questions have been raised(Zuo Zhang,2006)and yet to be answered on whether cross-cultural differences in self-construal(independent vs.inter-dependent or interpersonal)affect self-enhancement.Related to this cross-cultural question are the developmental characteristics of self-enhancement that also require further investigations.The purpose of this study was to examine the relationship between interpersonal relations and self-enhancement among Chinese adolescents.We hypothesized that self-enhancement manifest itself differently depending on the Chinese interpersonal contexts.We tested this hypothesis in two experiments.In Experiment 1,we examined self-serving attribution as an explicit self-enhancement strategy under interpersonal comparison condition.In Experiment 2,we examined both explicit(self-serving attribution selective acceptance and refutation)and implicit self-enhancement strategies(e.g.,a measure of birthday preference)under interpersonal comparison versus non-interpersonal comparison conditions.One hundred and 67 students(81 males and 86 females,Mage = 21.51 years)participated in Experiment 1.We used two between-subject designs.One is a 2(feedback type:success,failure)× 2(relationship type:friends,strangers)× 2(research situation:public,private)between-subject design,with attribution of responsibility for the task outcome being the primary dependent variable.The other is a 2(attribution type:self-serving,self-effacing)× 2(feedback type:success,failure)× 2(relationship type:friends,strangers)design,with evaluation of attribution and intention to communicate being the dependent variables.In experiment 2,150 junior high school students(66 males and 84 females,Mage = 13.5 years),91 senior high school students(43 males and 48 females,Mage = 16.92 years),and 105 college students(68 males and 37 females,Mage = 19.6 years)were randomly assigned to between-subjects conditions.The independent variables were partner type,feedback type,and age group,whereas the dependent variables were birthday-number preference,attribution for the task outcome,and assessment of the effectiveness of the test respectively.In Experiment 1,participants exhibited self-effacing attribution under the interpersonal comparison condition,and their evaluations of self-effacing attribution were more positive than those of self-serving attribution in the negative feedback context.The evaluations of friends' attribution were more positive than those of strangers.' Moreover,adolescents liked to make friends with self-effacing rather than self-serving partners after receiving negative feedback.Results from Experiment 2 lent support to the existence of implicit self-enhancement.There was a birthday-number preference that was also independent of age.Adolescents under the interpersonal comparison condition did not show self-serving attribution.By contrast,under the non-interpersonal comparison condition,self-serving attribution was present nearly across all age groups,with junior high school students showing more self-serving attribution than senior high school or college students.When assessing the effectiveness of the test they have taken,adolescents showed selective acceptance and refutation,with junior high school students self-enhancing more than senior high school or college students.These results suggest that Chinese adolescents self-enhance in non-interpersonal comparison situations.However,the demonstration of this motive is somewhat implicit and is dependent on interpersonal contexts.Over the course of the adolescent years,implicit self-enhancement stays unchanged,whereas explicit self-enhancement which peaks in early adolescents decreases with age.