Representation, conceptualization and positioning in Critical Discourse Analysis
Piotr Cap
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/18773109-01202004
2020-08-19
International Review of Pragmatics
Abstract:Abstract The present paper explores the current nexus between Cognitive Linguistics ( CL ) and Critical Discourse Analysis ( CDA ), focusing on theories of conceptual positioning, distancing and perspective-taking in discourse space. It assesses the strengths, limitations, and prospects for further operationalization of positioning as a valid methodology in CDA , and political discourse studies in particular. In the first part, I review the cognitive models of positioning that have made the most significant contribution to CDA . Discussing Deictic Space Theory and Text World Theory, among others, I argue that these models reveal further theoretical potential which has not been exploited yet. While they offer a comprehensive and plausible account of how representations and ideologically charged worldviews are established, they fail to deliver a pragmatic explanation of how addressees are made to establish a worldview, in the service of speaker’s goals. The second part of the paper outlines Proximization Theory, a discursive model of crisis and conflict construction in political discourse. I argue that, unlike the other models, it fully captures the complex geopolitical and ideological positioning in political discourse space, providing a viable handle on the dynamics of conflict between the opposing ideologies of the space.