Comparison of the Evaluation Methods of Heavy Metal Sediment Pollution——Take Chongming Dongtan As an Example

Wan-lin ZHAI,Jiang-ping LONG

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1673-6125.2010.03.003

2010-01-01

Abstract:The contents of heavy metals of the Dongtan surface samples such as Hg,Cu,Cd,Pb,Zn are analyzed,and three evaluation methods such as the cumulative index,integrated pollution evaluation and potential ecological risk index are used to evaluate the polluted situation of Chongming Dongtan.The result of the cumulative index and the potential ecological risk index show that Dongtan is basically remaining a natural condition,only a few stations get a slight pollution of Hg and Pb;The result of integrated pollution assessment shows that the pollution of Chongming Dongtan reaches the alert level,and in the single factor evaluation,Cd contribution rate is the largest to the integrated pollution index,which indicates that the Cd pollution is more serious.Compared with the evaluation methods above,the cumulative index method is relatively simple,the integrated pollution evaluation method takes into account the maximum impact on soil quality,and emphasizing the most comprehensive pollution index with other methods,and the composite index is often high.The potential ecological risk index considers the toxic factor which has important influence on the environment and human health,so it has some practical significance.Each of three methods has its own advantages and disadvantages.