On the Ideals of Productivist and Developmental Social Policies:an Conceptual Inquiry and its Implications

Ka Lin,Huaijuan Zhao

2009-01-01

Abstract:After most advanced western industries adopted redistributivism as their general orientation of policy development(since 1960s),the issues of redistributive social poli- cy have been preoccupied the central of international social policy.This situation contributes a great deal to promote social equality and the welfare right of citizens in these states;however, to some extent,we can still see this dominance of the redistributive issue as a barrier for social policy discussions extended in new orientations.This effect is in particular visible in the developing and underdeveloped world,where the redistributive idea seems less applicable than the idea of developmentalism.Meanwhile,started from the late 1980s,the surged economic power of the East Asian states in the world system stimulated people's research interest in their welfare systems,in which an element of productivist social policy is embodied abd very essential.Nevertheless,in so far,both developmental and productivist ideas of social policies are not fully investigated but remained at the margin of international social policy debates.Accordingly,this article will conduct a conceptual inquiry about the content,features and their associated contexts of these two policy models.The paper proposes to evalutate"productivist social policy"as a specific policy model,and underscoring its meaning not only from a negative view but also by a positive light.Such work may enhance readers' senses of comparison and help them with a better understanding about the diversity of policy models.It can also be useful to generate new ideas about global social policy, in order to search for new policy measures to cope with the challenge from current world's financial crisis.