Abstract:The 16S rRNA gene has been extensively used as a molecular marker to explore evolutionary relationships and profile microbial composition throughout various environments. Despite its convenience and prevalence, limitations are inevitable. Variable copy numbers, intragenomic heterogeneity, and low taxonomic resolution have caused biases in estimating microbial diversity. Here, analysis of 24,248 complete prokaryotic genomes indicated that the 16S rRNA gene copy number ranged from 1 to 37 in bacteria and 1 to 5 in archaea, and intragenomic heterogeneity was observed in 60% of prokaryotic genomes, most of which were below 1%. The overestimation of microbial diversity caused by intragenomic variation and the underestimation introduced by interspecific conservation were calculated when using full-length or partial 16S rRNA genes. Results showed that, at the 100% threshold, microbial diversity could be overestimated by as much as 156.5% when using the full-length gene. The V4 to V5 region-based analyses introduced the lowest overestimation rate (4.4%) but exhibited slightly lower species resolution than other variable regions under the 97% threshold. For different variable regions, appropriate thresholds rather than the canonical value 97% were proposed for minimizing the risk of splitting a single genome into multiple clusters and lumping together different species into the same cluster. This study has not only updated the 16S rRNA gene copy number and intragenomic variation information for the currently available prokaryotic genomes, but also elucidated the biases in estimating prokaryotic diversity with quantitative data, providing references for choosing amplified regions and clustering thresholds in microbial community surveys.IMPORTANCE Microbial diversity is typically analyzed using marker gene-based methods, of which 16S rRNA gene sequencing is the most widely used approach. However, obtaining an accurate estimation of microbial diversity remains a challenge, due to the intragenomic variation and low taxonomic resolution of 16S rRNA genes. Comprehensive examination of the bias in estimating such prokaryotic diversity using 16S rRNA genes within ever-increasing prokaryotic genomes highlights the importance of the choice of sequencing regions and clustering thresholds based on the specific research objectives. Microbial diversity is typically analyzed using marker gene-based methods, of which 16S rRNA gene sequencing is the most widely used approach. However, obtaining an accurate estimation of microbial diversity remains a challenge, due to the intragenomic variation and low taxonomic resolution of 16S rRNA genes.

Could nested PCR be applicable for the study of microbial diversity?

Comparison of Microbial Diversity Determined with the Same Variable Tag Sequence Extracted from Two Different PCR Amplicons

16S—23S rRNA基因区间细菌鉴定实验研究

Study on the Bacterial Identification Using 16S-23S Rrna Gene Spacer Regions

Improvement of DGGE analysis by modifications of PCR protocols for analysis of microbial community members with low abundance

[Influence of PCR cycle number on microbial diversity analysis through next generation sequencing]

Evaluation of Pcr-Generated Chimeras: Mutations, and Heteroduplexes with 16s Rrna Gene-Based Cloning

High-density universal 16S rRNA microarray analysis reveals broader diversity than typical clone library when sampling the environment

Analysis of microbial diversity by pyrosequencing the small-subunit ribosomal RNA without PCR amplification

A 16S rDNA PCR-based theoretical to actual delta approach on culturable mock communities revealed severe losses of diversity information

Application of Nested PCR in P1-RFLP for Genotyping Mycoplasma Pneumoniae Strains

[Molecular Diagnosis of the Specific DNA Patterns of 16S-23S Rrna Gene of Bacteria].

Biased Diversity Metrics Revealed by Bacterial 16S Pyrotags Derived from Different Primer Sets.

Application of Method to Eliminate the Heteroduplex Caused in the Course of PCR to Microbial Molecular Ecology

Bias caused by template annealing in the amplification of mixtures of 16S rRNA genes by PCR

Metagenome complexity and template length are the main causes of bias in PCR-based bacteria community analysis

Microbial Diversity Biased Estimation Caused by Intragenomic Heterogeneity and Interspecific Conservation of 16S Rrna Genes.

Comparative analysis of two 16S rRNA gene-based PCR primer sets provides insight into the diversity distribution patterns of anammox bacteria in different environments

Comparison of an automated DNA extraction and 16S rDNA real time PCR/sequencing diagnostic method using optimized reagents with culture during a 15-month study using specimens from sterile body sites

Characterization of microbial diversity by determining terminal restriction fragment length polymorphisms of genes encoding 16S rRNA

Reproducibility and quantitation of amplicon sequencing-based detection