Comparative study on nylon bag technique and feacal fluid method for determining organic matter and protein digestion

ZHANG Yong-gen,WANG Zhi-bo,SONG Ping,LI Zhi-ming
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1005-9369.2005.06.012
2005-01-01
Abstract:It is well known that dry matter digestibility is one of the most useful measures of the nutritional value of a feedstuff.Nylon bag digestion technique has been long used but met many limitations.A more serious practical disadvantage is the need for fitulated animals to provide the rumen fluid.Instead,a new procedure using fecal liquor as an inoculum was developed and proved successful with a range of feedstuffs.This method has a valuable feature,that is no need for fistulated ruminants and suitable for batch operation under normal commercial conditions.However,some questions remain as to potential use of faeces as an inoculum.The objective of the study was to search for a in vitro technique for determination of forage digestibility with precision,suitability and low-cost.The 29 varieties of legume and grass forage crop were planted in early May in 2003 at the experimental field of Heilongjiang Agriculture Academy under the same soil and environmental conditions.Relationship between nylon bag method and fecal liquor method for determination of DM or CP degradability of forages was investigated.The results indicated that there was a very significant correlation between estimates of fecal liquor method and values of nylon bag method(P <0.01),estimates of fecal liquor method(X) and values of nylon bag method(Y) had following regression equation,namely,Y=0.97X+5.57,R2=0.82,RSD=4.46(for organic matter),Y=0.90X+7.43,R2=0.94,RSD=2.18(for protein).There was a consistent ranking sequence in the two methods based on degradability.However,OM and CP degradability determined by using fecal fluid were 10.3% and 4.84% lower than values determined by using nylon bag technique,respectively(P >0.05).On the basis of these results,it was concluded that the faeces liquor method would seem to have a distinct advantage in use.It is also suggested the method for determining OM and CP degradability using fecal liquor was appropriate for batch operation.However,more research with a wide range of feedstuff is required to confirm feasibility of the new method.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?