Value of acoustic radiation force impulse imaging in the differential diagnosis between benign and malignant solitary solid thyroid nodules
ZHANG Jing,XU Hui-xiong,ZHANG Yi-feng,XU Jun-mei,LIU Chang,GUO Le-hang,LIU Lin-na
DOI: https://doi.org/10.7507/1007-9424.20140262
2013-01-01
Abstract:Objective To explore the value of virtual touch tissue imaging(VTI) and virtual touch tissue quantification(VTQ)of acoustic radiation force impulse(ARFI)elastography in the differential diagnosis between benign and malignant solitary solid thyroid nodules in ultrasound.Methods The ARFI elastography characteristics and ultrasound(US) features of 42 histologically proven solid or predominantly solid thyroid nodules in 42 patients with a solitary nodule were reviewed.The pathological diagnosis was the gold standard and the sensitivity,specificity,positive predictive value(PPV) and negative predictive value(NPV) of US,VTQ and VTI in diagnosis of malignant solitary solid thyroid nodules were caculated.Results Forty-two nodules included 30 benign lesions(16 nodular goiters,13 adenomatous goiters and one subacute thyroiditis)and 12 malignant lesions(papillary carcinomas).The sonographic features that suggested malignancy include hypoechogenicity,irregular or microlobulated margin,microcalcification,intranodular bloodflow and taller than wide shape.Forteen nodules(four benign nodules and ten malignant nodules) had three or more of these features and 28 nodules(26 benign nodules and two malignant nodules) had less than three of these features.The sensitivity,specificity,PPV and NPV of US was 83.3%(10/12),86.7%(26/30),71.4%(10/14) and 92.9%(26/28).The shear wave velocities(SWV) of 15 nodules(five benign nodules and ten malignant nodules) were greater than or equal to 2.87 m/s and those of 27 nodules(25 benign nodules and two malignant nodules)were less than 2.87 m/s.The sensitivity,specificity,PPV and NPV of VTQ was 83.3%(10/12),83.3%(25/30),66.7%(10/15) and 92.6%(25/27),respectively.The VTI scores of 19 nodules(eight benign nodules and 11 malignant nodules) were greater than or equal to Ⅳand those of 23 nodules(22 benign nodules and one malignant nodule)were less than Ⅳ.The sensitivity,specificity,PPV and NPV of VTI was 91.7%(11/12),73.3%(22/30),57.8%(11/19) and 95.7%(22/23),respectively.The sensitivity,specificity,PPV and NPV of US combining VTI was 91.7%(11/12),80.0%(24/30),64.7%(11/17) and 96.0%(24/25),respectively.The sensitivity,specificity,PPV and NPV of US combining VTQ was 91.7%(11/12),83.3%(25/30),68.8%(11/16) and 96.2%(25/26),respectively.Conclusion ARFI alone is not superior to US in predicting malignancy in thyroid nodules but can be used as a supplementary tool to improve the diagnostic level.