Effect of insufficient effort on cognitive assessments in patients with schizophrenia

CHEN Nan,ZOU Yi-Zhuang,TAN Shu-Ping,CUI Jie-Feng,FAN Hong-Zhen,YAO Jing
2013-01-01
Abstract:Objective:To explore the effects of different levels of effort on the cognitive assessments in patients w ith schizophrenia. Methods: One hundred and ten patients w ith schizophrenia and 110 normal controls w ere tested w ith the M ATRICS Consensus Cognitive Battery( M CCB) and Word M emory Test( WM T). The tw o groups w ere divided into 4 subgroups of normal effort( NE) and insufficient effort( IE) on WM T,namely,Sch-NE group, Sch-IE group,Con-NE group and Con-IE group. The patients w ith schizophrenia w ere also tested w ith the Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale( PANSS),Raven' s Standard progressive M atrices( SPM) and Wisconsin Card Sorting Test( WCST). Results: The WM T failure rate w as significantly higher in schizophrenia patients than in normal controls( 37% vs. 8%,P < 0. 001). The patients w ith schizophrenia generally performed w orse than the normal controls in all WM T scores [e. g.,Immediate Recognition,( 91. 0 ± 11. 7) vs.( 96. 8 ± 4. 3),P < 0. 001]. With WM T mean score w as introduced as covariate variable in the statistical analyses,the patients w ith schizophrenia generally performed w orse than the normal controls in all cognitive tests except for category fluency test [e. g.,M CCB total score,( 37. 8 ± 10. 4) vs.( 50. 9 ± 8. 8),P < 0. 001]. The effect of effort w as significant for all cognitive tests except maze test( P < 0. 001),and w as alw ays considerably smaller( Eta2betw een 1. 7%- 10. 8%) than the group differences( Eta2ranged betw een 6. 2%- 24. 7%). The Sch-NE group generally performed higher than the Sch-NE group in all cognitive tests except for trail making test and maze test [e. g.,M CCB total score,( 40. 4 ± 9. 8) vs.( 32. 6 ± 9. 6),P < 0. 001]. The WM T scores w ere positively correlated w ith the scores of M CCB and WCST( r = 0. 19- 0. 45,Ps < 0. 05),and negatively correlated w ith the symptom scale scores( r =- 0. 20-- 0. 32,Ps < 0. 05). Conclusion: It suggests that mental effort should be taken into consideration in cognitive assessments of schizophrenic patients. Controlling for this variable may have a considerable impact on research,assessment and treatment of cognitive disorders in patients w ith schizophrenia.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?