The diversified development of historic towns based on the integrated evaluation system of heritage conservation and tourism development in Jiangsu
Shi'en Zhong,Jinhe Zhang,Jinkun Sun
DOI: https://doi.org/10.11821/dlyj201507016
2015-01-01
Geographical Research
Abstract:Tourism development is often the primary and optimal way for historic townsu0027 heritage conservation and socio-economic revitalization. After defining the concept of historic town destination, this paper describes the evolving stages of historic towns in Jiangsu, from geographical tradition of regional studies, and answers the practical question of how many historic towns there are in Jiangsu province(116). The main findings include: It is not necessarily linked between a historic townu0027s outstanding universal value(OUV) and its physical, economic and social revitalizations. To boost a historic townu0027s revitalization, it needs to consider the historic townu0027s OUV and its use way(such as tourism), and it also needs to consider whether or not the traditional hub function linking a city and its surrounding rural areas still exists. And it needs to evaluate the historic townu0027s regional economic and social backgrounds, whether or not there are adjacent superior resources or promising external opportunities. The innovative development of Zhouzhuang and Tongli, i.e., which put heritage protection and tourism development together, have appeared many negative effects when Zhouzhuang and Tongli subsequently enter the stages of stagnation and post- stagnation.According to Butleru0027s TALC theory, when the various negative regional impacts exceed the positive regional impacts, a destination will inevitably lose its attractiveness. There are drawbacks for present evaluation systems to guide the historic townsu0027 heritage conservation and tourism development. The evaluation system of Chinau0027s historic towns mostly evaluates the heritage value and ignores the valueu0027s uses. And the evaluation system of Chinau0027s characteristic landscape and tourist towns, have not considered the comprehensive influencing factors of the tourism industry. So this paper proposes an integrated evaluation system including a lot of indexes helpfully to measure a historic townu0027s heritage value, tourism development and its innovations. It helps to answer whether or not a historic town has the suitability and uses its heritage value to boost tourism development. After grading, this paper differentiates the 116 historic towns in Jiangsu into three development choices, i.e., brand ones, updated ones and potential ones. The evaluation system also helps to guide heritage conservation. Some need entire conservation, and some need partial conservation while the others need dotted ways. This paper also suggests an equilibrium analysis model, and three recommendations are proposed,including the conservation priority strategy, the marketing priority strategy and the balanced strategy. The study finds that it needs to consider the two concepts of region and scale together in the geographical tradition of regional studies. The regional disparities on meso- scale(Jiangsu) can be homogenous on large- scale(the national scale). Considering the regional disparities on meso-scale, also it is ncessary to consider the small-scale(prefecture-level cities in Jiangsu) and the further nested historic town scale based on the results of the evaluation system in a practical way.