Abstract: Recent studies have extended the Black–Scholes model to incorporate either stochastic interest rates or stochastic volatility. But, there is not yet any comprehensive empirical study demonstrating whether and by how much each generalized feature will improve option pricing and hedging performance. This paper fills this gap by first developing an implementable option model in closed-form that admits both stochastic volatility and stochastic interest rates and that is parsimonious in the number of parameters. The model includes many known ones as special cases. Based on the model, both delta-neutral and single-instrument minimum-variance hedging strategies are derived analytically. Using S&P 500 option prices, we then compare the pricing and hedging performance of this model with that of three existing ones that respectively allow for (i) constant volatility and constant interest rates (the Black–Scholes), (ii) constant volatility but stochastic interest rates, and (iii) stochastic volatility but constant interest rates. Overall, incorporating stochastic volatility and stochastic interest rates produces the best performance in pricing and hedging, with the remaining pricing and hedging errors no longer systematically related to contract features. The second performer in the horse-race is the stochastic volatility model, followed by the stochastic interest rates model and then by the Black–Scholes.

Do S&P 500 Index Options Violate the Martingale Restriction?

Martingale defects in the volatility surface and bubble conditions in the underlying

Volatility Risk Premium, Good Volatility and Bad Volatility: Evidence from SSE 50 ETF Options

Is the Nonlinear Hedge of Options More Effective?-Evidence from the SSE 50 ETF Options in China

Stochastic arbitrage with market index options

Determinants of S&P 500 Index Option Returns

Is Investor Misreaction Economically Significant? Evidence from Short- and Long-term S&P 500 Index Options

Construction and Hedging of Equity Index Options Portfolios

Modelling the skew and smile of SPX and DAX index options using the Shifted Log-Normal and SABR stochastic models

Psychological barriers and option pricing in a local volatility model

Martingales, the Efficient Market Hypothesis, and Spurious Stylized Facts

Index option returns and generalized entropy bounds

Pricing and Hedging Long-Term Options

Robust pricing and hedging under trading restrictions and the emergence of local martingale models

Modeling the Implied Volatility Surface-: A Study for S&P 500 Index Option

Option Pricing and Hedging Performance Under Stochastic Volatility and Stochastic Interest Rates

The Impact of Position Limits on Options Trading

Investor Sentiment and Option Prices

On the stability of call/put option's prices in incomplete models under statistical estimations

Analysis of Option Trading Strategies Based on the Relation of Implied and Realized S&P500 Volatilities

Does the behaviour of the asset tell us anything about the option price formula? A cautionary tale