The effect of vitrification and programmed freezing on frozen-thawed human ovarian cortex tissue
X. Wang,C. Fang,C. Di,H. Liu,X. Liang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fertnstert.2015.07.824
IF: 6.7
2015-01-01
Fertility and Sterility
Abstract:ObjectiveIt has been long remained controversial whether vitrification, compared with programmed freezing, is better for ovarian fertility preservation. Therefore, this study aimed at comparison of the effects of these two techniques on the frozen-thawed human ovarian tissues, to provide some experimental evidences to select a better method to preserve women fertility.DesignOvarian tissues came from cases of partial ovariectomy, with necessity of diagnosis or treatment. And all the pathological reports told neither tumor cell metastasis in the ovarian tissue nor existence of other nidi. In each case, the cortex was cut into small pieces, followed by randomly divided into Fresh (F) group, Vitrification (V) group and Programmed Freezing (PF) group. Morphology changes, apoptosis in situ, follicle viability and secretion function were compared with self-control method and in-vitro cultivation.Materials and MethodsOvarian tissues came from 6 cases, which met the above criteria. The morphology of tissues were examined by HE staining. The cell apoptosis in situ was analyzed by TUNEL assay. Neutral red staining and CaAM/EthD-1 staining were conducted respectively after collagenase-1 digestion of frozen-thawed tissues, and the survival rate of small follicles was analyzed. During in vitro culture of frozen-thawed ovarian tissues, the secretion level of estrogen (E2) and progesterone (P4) in media were examined and analyzed at Day 2, Day 4, Day 6 and Day 8.ResultsThe morphology of follicles and stroma cells in both V Group and PF Group were similar as F Group. The apoptosis in situ showed no significance between V Group and F Group, while apoptosis in PF Group is significantly higher than other two groups. After frozen-thawed, no significant differences were showed in assessment of viability of small follicles between PF Group and V Group. Analysis of E2 and P4 level showed that secretion of E2 had a tendency to change over time, and time effect varies with grouping. It increased significantly higher in PF Group at Day 4 and Day 8, but similar at Day 6, when compared with V Group. The secretion of P4 also had a tendency to change over time, but no significant differences were found in the effect of interaction of time and grouping, neither in the grouping effect.ConclusionsBoth of vitrification and programmed freezing can well preserve the morphological characteristics of ovarian cortex tissue, but vitrification may be better for protection of DNA integrity in cells. Both of vitrification and programmed freezing can well preserve the viability of small follicles in frozen-thawed tissues. Both of the frozen-thawed tissues after vitrification and programmed freezing can recover secretion function. And functional reconstruction of frozen-thawed ovarian tissues with these two techniques still needs further researches. ObjectiveIt has been long remained controversial whether vitrification, compared with programmed freezing, is better for ovarian fertility preservation. Therefore, this study aimed at comparison of the effects of these two techniques on the frozen-thawed human ovarian tissues, to provide some experimental evidences to select a better method to preserve women fertility. It has been long remained controversial whether vitrification, compared with programmed freezing, is better for ovarian fertility preservation. Therefore, this study aimed at comparison of the effects of these two techniques on the frozen-thawed human ovarian tissues, to provide some experimental evidences to select a better method to preserve women fertility. DesignOvarian tissues came from cases of partial ovariectomy, with necessity of diagnosis or treatment. And all the pathological reports told neither tumor cell metastasis in the ovarian tissue nor existence of other nidi. In each case, the cortex was cut into small pieces, followed by randomly divided into Fresh (F) group, Vitrification (V) group and Programmed Freezing (PF) group. Morphology changes, apoptosis in situ, follicle viability and secretion function were compared with self-control method and in-vitro cultivation. Ovarian tissues came from cases of partial ovariectomy, with necessity of diagnosis or treatment. And all the pathological reports told neither tumor cell metastasis in the ovarian tissue nor existence of other nidi. In each case, the cortex was cut into small pieces, followed by randomly divided into Fresh (F) group, Vitrification (V) group and Programmed Freezing (PF) group. Morphology changes, apoptosis in situ, follicle viability and secretion function were compared with self-control method and in-vitro cultivation. Materials and MethodsOvarian tissues came from 6 cases, which met the above criteria. The morphology of tissues were examined by HE staining. The cell apoptosis in situ was analyzed by TUNEL assay. Neutral red staining and CaAM/EthD-1 staining were conducted respectively after collagenase-1 digestion of frozen-thawed tissues, and the survival rate of small follicles was analyzed. During in vitro culture of frozen-thawed ovarian tissues, the secretion level of estrogen (E2) and progesterone (P4) in media were examined and analyzed at Day 2, Day 4, Day 6 and Day 8. Ovarian tissues came from 6 cases, which met the above criteria. The morphology of tissues were examined by HE staining. The cell apoptosis in situ was analyzed by TUNEL assay. Neutral red staining and CaAM/EthD-1 staining were conducted respectively after collagenase-1 digestion of frozen-thawed tissues, and the survival rate of small follicles was analyzed. During in vitro culture of frozen-thawed ovarian tissues, the secretion level of estrogen (E2) and progesterone (P4) in media were examined and analyzed at Day 2, Day 4, Day 6 and Day 8. ResultsThe morphology of follicles and stroma cells in both V Group and PF Group were similar as F Group. The apoptosis in situ showed no significance between V Group and F Group, while apoptosis in PF Group is significantly higher than other two groups. After frozen-thawed, no significant differences were showed in assessment of viability of small follicles between PF Group and V Group. Analysis of E2 and P4 level showed that secretion of E2 had a tendency to change over time, and time effect varies with grouping. It increased significantly higher in PF Group at Day 4 and Day 8, but similar at Day 6, when compared with V Group. The secretion of P4 also had a tendency to change over time, but no significant differences were found in the effect of interaction of time and grouping, neither in the grouping effect. The morphology of follicles and stroma cells in both V Group and PF Group were similar as F Group. The apoptosis in situ showed no significance between V Group and F Group, while apoptosis in PF Group is significantly higher than other two groups. After frozen-thawed, no significant differences were showed in assessment of viability of small follicles between PF Group and V Group. Analysis of E2 and P4 level showed that secretion of E2 had a tendency to change over time, and time effect varies with grouping. It increased significantly higher in PF Group at Day 4 and Day 8, but similar at Day 6, when compared with V Group. The secretion of P4 also had a tendency to change over time, but no significant differences were found in the effect of interaction of time and grouping, neither in the grouping effect. ConclusionsBoth of vitrification and programmed freezing can well preserve the morphological characteristics of ovarian cortex tissue, but vitrification may be better for protection of DNA integrity in cells. Both of vitrification and programmed freezing can well preserve the viability of small follicles in frozen-thawed tissues. Both of the frozen-thawed tissues after vitrification and programmed freezing can recover secretion function. And functional reconstruction of frozen-thawed ovarian tissues with these two techniques still needs further researches. Both of vitrification and programmed freezing can well preserve the morphological characteristics of ovarian cortex tissue, but vitrification may be better for protection of DNA integrity in cells. Both of vitrification and programmed freezing can well preserve the viability of small follicles in frozen-thawed tissues. Both of the frozen-thawed tissues after vitrification and programmed freezing can recover secretion function. And functional reconstruction of frozen-thawed ovarian tissues with these two techniques still needs further researches.