Abstract:Explaining coexistence in species-rich communities of primary producers remains a challenge for ecologists because of their likely competition for shared resources. Following Hutchinson's seminal suggestion, many theoreticians have tried to create diversity through a fluctuating environment, which impairs or slows down competitive exclusion. However, fluctuating-environment models often only produce a dozen of coexisting species at best. Here, we investigate how to create richer communities in fluctuating environments, using an empirically parameterized model. Building on the forced Lotka-Volterra model of Scranton and Vasseur (Theor Ecol 9(3):353-363, 2016), inspired by phytoplankton communities, we have investigated the effect of two coexistence mechanisms, namely the storage effect and higher intra- than interspecific competition strengths (i.e., strong self-regulation). We tuned the intra/inter competition ratio based on empirical analyses, in which self-regulation dominates interspecific interactions. Although a strong self-regulation maintained more species (50%) than the storage effect (25%), we show that none of the two coexistence mechanisms considered could ensure the coexistence of all species alone. Realistic seasonal environments only aggravated that picture, as they decreased persistence relative to a random environment. However, strong self-regulation and the storage effect combined superadditively so that all species could persist with both mechanisms at work. Our results suggest that combining different coexistence mechanisms into community models might be more fruitful than trying to find which mechanism best explains diversity. We additionally highlight that while biomass-trait distributions provide some clues regarding coexistence mechanisms, they cannot indicate unequivocally which mechanisms are at play.

A competition model for a seasonally fluctuating nutrient

Competition for two essential resources with internal storage and periodic input

On A Mathematical Model Arising from Competition of Phytoplankton Species for A Single Nutrient with Internal Storage: Steady State Analysis

Exploitative Competition of Microorganisms for Two Complementary Nutrients in Continuous Cultures

Limiting Behavior For Competing Species

Periodic solutions for a delayed competitive chemostat model with periodic nutrient input and rate

Competition Between Microorganisms for a Single Limiting Resource with Cell Quota Structure and Spatial Variation

Global Dynamics of a Mathematical Model of Competition in the Chemostat: General Response Functions and Differential Death Rates

Coexistence Solutions of A Competition Model with Two Species in A Water Column

Competitive Exclusion of Microbial Species for a Single Nutrient with Internal Storage

A Periodic-Parabolic Droop Model for Two Species Competition in an Unstirred Chemostat

A Lotka–Volterra competition model with seasonal succession

A Survey of Mathematical Models with Variable Quotas

A Mathematical-Model of the Chemostat with Periodic Washout Rate

A Mathematical Theory for Single-Nutrient Competition in Continuous Cultures of Micro-Organisms

Dynamics of Two Phytoplankton Speciescompeting for Light and Nutrient with Internal Storage

Competition in the nutrient-driven self-cycling fermentation process

How self-regulation, the storage effect and their interaction contribute to coexistence in stochastic and seasonal environments

Mathematical analysis of two microbial species competing for two complementary resources with internal storages and different removal , dilution rates

Plasmid-bearing, Plasmid-Free Organisms Competing for Two Complementary Nutrients in a Chemostat.

Stochastic nutrient-plankton models