Huo 或 in Heng Xian of the Shanghai Museum’s Edition of Chu Bamboo Slips
Sixin Ding
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/15406253-0460304006
2019-03-03
Journal of Chinese Philosophy
Abstract:“ Huo ” 或 in “ Heng Xian ” 恆先 of the Chu bamboo slips in the Shanghai Museum is a significant concept in cosmology and cosmogony. “ Huo ,” as a cosmogonic period, is after “ heng ” 恆 (the permanent), but prior to qi 氣 (material force), hence it is relatively important. This term in the manuscript is used as an indefinite pronoun, meaning “something”, rather than “exist” (as a verb), “indefinitely/ maybe” (as an adverb) or “a state between being and nothingness”. However, in the cosmogonic sequence, it is indeed intermediate between nothingness (“ heng xian ”, the permanent beginning) and being ( qi , or you 有, being/to be). That “ huo ,” as an indefinite pronoun, can be used as a philosophical concept is testified by “ Bai Xin ” 白心(Purifying the Heart-mind) in the Book of Guanzi 管子 and “ Ze yang ” 則陽 in the Book of Zhuangzi , in which the term “huo” also means “something.” “ Heng Xian ” uses an indefinite pronoun “ huo ” to refer to a stage in the genesis of the cosmos. This shows, on the one hand, that its author has contemplated cosmology more profoundly; on the other hand, it shows that the author’s knowledge about the structure of cosmogony has not yet been fully developed. Moreover, the concepts “ huo ” and “ heng xian ” both develop the notion implicit in the concept of “ heng .”