Cardiac Anesthesia Risk Evaluation Score and European System for Cardiac Operative Risk Evaluation for Chinese patients undergoing coronary artery bypass grafting:a comparison of risk prediction capability

PAN Fangli,CHEN Jie,WANG Xiangrui
2011-01-01
Abstract:Objective To know whether the Cardiac Anesthesia Risk Evaluation(CARE)score is suitable for Chinese patients undergoing coronary artery bypass grafting(CABG),and to compare the values of CARE and European System for Cardiac Operative Risk Evaluation(EuroSCORE)in predicting the outcomes of CABG patients(operative mortality,postoperative complications,hospital stay,postoperative hospital stay,and days in ICU).Methods The clinical data of 212 patients who received CABG during Jun.2007 to Dec.2008 were retrospectively analyzed.They were all assessed by CARE system and EuroSCORE system by an anesthesiologist.The correlations of the two risk models with length of hospital stay,postoperative hospital stay and ICU stay were assessed by correlation analysis.Calibration and discrimination for predicting the outcomes were assessed by Pearson chi-square goodness-of-fit test and area under the receiver operating characteristic curve,respectively.Results The correlation between EuroSCORE and length of hospital stay,postoperative hospital stay and ICU stay was significant(all P<0.05).The correlation between the CARE score and length of hospital stay was not significant(P>0.05),and the correlation between the CARE score and postoperative hospital stay and ICU stay was significant(both P<0.01).The calibration analysis revealed no significant difference between the expected and the observed mortality for the two risk models(χ2=1.117 2,1.399 2;P=0.952 6,0.496 8).The CARE score also had acceptable calibration in predicting morbidity(χ2=7.802 3,P=0.167 5),but had an unacceptable one in predicting prolonged hospital stay(χ2=21.266 9,P=0.012 6).The areas under the receiver operating characteristic curves for mortality were 0.723 with the CARE score and 0.907 with the EuroSCORE;and the areas under the receiver operating characteristic curves for morbidity were 0.648 with the CARE score and 0.684 with the EuroSCORE.Conclusions Both CARE score and EuroSCORE have a satisfactory capability for predicting the mortality,postoperative hospital stay and ICU stay in Chinese patients undergoing CABG.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?