Effects of Soil Water Contents on Competitive Abilities and Yield of Two Winter Wheat Cultivars

LIU Lin,XU Bing-Cheng,LI Feng-Min,MA Shou-Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1000-0933.2007.08.042

2007-01-01

Acta Ecologica Sinica

Abstract:The aim of this research is to study the effects of different soil water contents on competitive abilities and grain yields of two winter wheat cultivars(Triticum aestivum L.),i.e.(modern cultivar Changwu135(A)and old cultivar Pingliang40(B)).In the pot experiment,we adopted the ecological replacement series to design 6 seeding proportions with the same density,and two soil water contents were 75%-80% and 40%-45% of field capacity for dry wet conditions,respectively.The results showed that the modern cultivar Changwu135 had higher yield than the old cultivar Pingliang40 under dry conditions(A:27.59 g vs.B:24.91 g),however,there was no significant difference in grain yield between two cultivars under wet conditions(A:35.86 g vs.B:36.46 g).The cultivar Pingliang40 had significant higher relative yield than modern cultivar Changwu135 under two water treatments with mixed-seeding way.Linear slopes were used to describe the variation of seeding proportion versus grain yield.The grain yield value decreased more steeply in Pingliang40(slope 36.237)than Changwu135(slope 35.468)under wet conditions.It is showed that Pingliang40 had a stronger competitive ability on grain yield in mixed-seeding way.The value of relative total yield increased with the seeding proportion of old cultivar increasing under two water treatments.And the other biological characteristics related to yield also had the same variations as grain yield.It is showed that the dominant cultivar in mixed seedling had lower grain yield than that in monoculture,and there was a negative relationship between the competitive ability and productivity.The accumulated dry matter weight after anthesis of old cultivar Pingliang40 was lower in monoculture(A:0.67 g/pot vs.B:0.55 g/pot)but higher in mixed seeding than modern cultivar Changwu135(average of A:0.58 g/pot vs.B:0.71 g/pot),which led to Pingliang40 had lower yield in monoculture but higher yield in mixed seeding.However,the modern cultivar Changwu135 had a reverse result on the accumulated dry matter weight after anthesis.And the accumulation coefficient had the same variations as the accumulated dry matter weight after anthesis.Shoot biomass and root biomass of Pingliang40 were significantly higher than Changwu135 under wet conditions(shoot biomass increased 22.80 g/pot,root biomass increased 1.48 g/pot)and dry conditions(shoot biomass increased 13.93 g/pot,root biomass increased 2.28 g/pot).The value of water consumption of old cultivar Pingliang40 was significantly higher than that of Changwu135(increased 2.72k g/pot under wet condition and 0.98k g/pot under dry condition).In addition,the cultivar Pingliang40 had a lower ratio of water consumption to root biomass than Changwu135(decreased 0.02 kg/g under wet condition and 0.23 kg/g under dry condition),which indicated that old cultivar Pingliang40 had developed roots,higher shoot biomass and lower yield,thus it can consume less water to grow unit root biomass.However,the modern cultivar Changwu135 had reverse results in mixed seeding.In conclusion,the two cultivars which had similar biological characters,the old cultivar Pingliang40 had stronger competitive ability than the modern cultivar Changwu135 under two soil water content treatments because of its developed root biomass and more water consumption.And the competitive ability of Pingliang40 under wet condition was weaker than that under dry treatment.Although modern cultivar Changwu135 had lower root biomass and less water consumption,it had a higher grain yield.The experiment also suggested that the crop productivity increased as the root biomass decreased and the competition ability for water resource weakened.