Abstract:Much of the literature exploring Chinese international student engagement with critical thinking in Western universities draws on reductive essentialisations of 'Confucianism' in efforts to explain cross-cultural differences. In this paper I review literature problematising these tendencies. I then shift focus from inferences about how philosophy shapes culture and individual students, toward drawing on philosophy as a 'living' resource for understanding and shaping the ideal of critical thinking. A cross disciplinary approach employs historical overview and philosophical interpretation within and beyond the Confucian tradition to exemplify three types of criticality common in Chinese philosophy. These are criticality within tradition, criticality of tradition, and critical integration of traditions. The result is a refutation of claims or inferences (intentional or implicit) that Chinese philosophy is not conducive to criticality. While this paper focuses on types of criticality, it also reveals a common method of criticality within Chinese philosophy, in the form of 'creation through transmission'. This resonates with recent research calling for less confrontational and more dialogical engagement with critical processes. However, I also draw attention to examples of confrontational argumentation within Chinese philosophy, which may provide valuable resources for educators and students. Finally, I conclude careful and explicit consideration is needed regarding the types of criticality sought within Western universities to prevent educators and students from 'speaking past' one and other instead of 'speaking with' one and other in critical dialogue.

On the Shortcomings and Reconstruction of Thinking of Understanding in Chinese Philosophy

A Reconstruction of Chinese Philosophy, from Ancient Philosophy to a "New Tradition"

Introspection and Re-construction: the Study Pattern about the Modern Chinese Enlightening Principle

The Disenchantment and Reconstruction of Chinese Traditional Theory of Human Nature

The Possibility of the Recommencement of Philosophy in Chinese Thought

On Reverse Analogical Interpretation in Chinese Philosophical Studies

On the Study of Foreign Philosophy in Chinese Cultural Construction and Its Future

Understanding,Critique and Constitution

On Mid-View Thinking in Chinese Philosophy

Reflection and Assumption on the Reconstruction of Public Philosophy in China

China's Resources for Constructing the Contemporary Philosophy of Culture

Re-understanding Marx:Marx's Philosophy in Yu Wu-jin's Perspective

On “the Modernity of Chinese Philosophy”

Lack and Reconstruction of Enlightenment——Thinking on the Development of the Contemporary Chinese Culture

On Qian Zhongshu’s Comparative Study of Chinese and Western Philosophies

Chinese philosophy: A characterization

Paradigm Reconstruction and Criticism Practice

On The Contemporary Construction Of The Chinese System Of Academic Discourse

A Critical Survey of Some Recent Philosophical Research in China

Exploring Criticality in Chinese Philosophy: Refuting Generalisations and Supporting Critical Thinking

A Reflection on the Development of Chinese Philosophy in the Past One Hundred Years