The Unorthodox Origins of the Asian Currency Crisis: Evidence from Logit Estimation
Wing Thye Woo,Patrick D. Carleton,Brian P. Rosario
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1355/ae17-2b
2000-01-01
Asean Economic Bulletin
Abstract:I. Introduction The Asian financial crisis, which started on 2 July 1997, was the third region-wide currency crisis in the 1990s. The first regional currency collapse was in Europe in 1992-93 and the second was in Latin America in 1994-95. One would have hoped that the voluminous research dissecting these earlier crises would have given governments and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) some ideas on how to read signs of an approaching regional storm. However, no red lights appeared to have flashed warnings of a crisis for the entire East Asian region before mid- 1997. Only Thailand, with its large current account deficits in 1995 and 1996, looked a possible candidate for a devaluation, and even then the cautionary remarks on Thailand were hedged because these current accounts were seen to be financed by private capital inflows and hence to be sustainable in the medium term. Were the exchange rate collapses in 1997 in Asia really unexpected as claimed by the governments in these countries? It would be naive, of course, not to recognize that these governments would find it convenient to attribute the currency collapses on financial contagion, and divert blame away from any bad policies the governments had implemented. But it would be equally naive not to recognize that financial panic has been part of the human condition ever since asset markets were established.(1) This article attempts to answer whether the currency crises in Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, South Korea and Thailand (henceforth known as the Asian Crisis-5) in 1997-98 were due to a deterioration in their macroeconomic fundamentals or due to financial contagion. Our analysis proceeds in two parts. In the first part, we construct a new real exchange rate index, the Competitor-Weighted Real Exchange Rate (CWRER) for each of the Asian Crisis-5, that emphasizes the currency and price movements of the countries that compete against its top 10 exports. The question asked in the first part is whether loss in trade competitiveness was the over-riding reason for the crisis. The results were ambiguous. In the second part of the paper, we use a richer set of fundamentals to construct a logit model that allowed us to formally estimate the probability of a currency crisis occurring for the five Asian countries in 1997, given the information set that existed in 1996. Our results show that the macroeconomic fundamentals did not predict the currency crises -- thus supporting the claim that the Asian currency crisis was unexpected by investors, governments, and the IMF. We interpret this result as evidence that financial contagion was the main cause of the Asian crisis. This paper is organized as follows. Section II reviews the literature on currency crises. Section III discusses the movements in the real exchange rate of the Asian Crisis-5. Section IV reports the results of the logit estimations. Finally, Section V presents our conclusions. II. Literature Review Roughly speaking, the theoretical literature on currency crisis has gone through three generations. The first generation models identify the source of currency crisis to be misalignment between macroeconomic policies, and the value at which the currency is pegged. The second-generation models emphasize the existence of multiple equilibria and self-fulfilling prophecies. The third generation models highlight the dire consequences of over-investment induced by a moral hazard created either by implicit government guarantee of private debt or by implicit guarantee of a country's foreign debt by the International Monetary Fund (IMF). Krugman (1979) is typical of first generation models. An over-expansionary fiscal deficit is financed by money creation, and this leads to a deficit in the balance of payments that requires the government to run down its foreign exchange reserves to defend the exchange rate peg. Since the country's stock of foreign reserves is finite, the steady decline in the foreign reserves of the central bank will increase the number of speculators who recognize that a devaluation would be forthcoming. …