Ancestral Memory, Homeland Symbol, and Ethnic Group History: Interpreting the Migrant Legend of the Big Pagoda Tree in Hongtong, Shanxi

Zhao Shiyu

2006-01-01

Historical Research

Abstract:The migrant legend of the Big Pagoda Tree in Hongtong, Shanxi has been prevalent in North China since the Ming and Qing dynasties, and is also seen in a number of lineage records and stele records. Researchers commonly see the legend as reflecting the great migration during the Hongwu and Yongle reigns of the Ming Dynasty, and Hongtong is thus regarded as a transit point for migrating flows in the government project of forced displacement of the time. However, there are still some unanswered questions. In fact, whether passed from mouth to mouth or recorded in lineage records, on steles or in local gazetteers, this legend reflects the collective memory of ancestral history and the life situation of the migrants. These memories show us the process by which a migrating lineage settled down and developed, as well as the changing relations among the Northern ethnic groups. They also reflect the social effects of state institutions, such as the system of Garrisons, on grassroots society, and the contemporary orientation or efforts for modernity that underlie reconstruction of the legend by the local gentry in the late Qing Dynasty and the Republican period. Hence research into the truthfulness of migrant legend about the Big Pagoda Tree becomes an effort to understand the historical development of local society. Legends and other oral materials are placed on the platform of historical memory, together with various folk documents, memoirs and gazetteers, to form an important and complex corpus of historical materials for understanding this matter.