From Music to Sound-Issues Concerning the Boundaries of Ethnomusicology

SONG Jin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-4270.2012.01.008

2012-01-01

Abstract:The breakthrough of the"music-in-itself"view is a progress.However,two deviations arise,confined to culture and sound respectively,which should be clarified by tackling the post-modernist "linguistic turn"and some related concepts,paradoxes and boundaries.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Music, Language, and Texts: Sound and Semiotic Ethnography

Paja Faudree

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-anthro-092611-145851

IF: 4.064

2012-10-21

Annual Review of Anthropology

Abstract:This review surveys recent research on language-music: the unified expressive field comprising sounded and textual signs whose segmentation into “language” and “music” is culturally constructed. I argue that approaching language-music semiotically will promote—alongside the discipline's emergent “auditory turn”—greater holism in anthropological practice if coupled to the joint effort of attending to textuality while decentering its primacy. I discuss recent scholarship that demonstrates, if often implicitly, the merit of this approach. I organize this work into three overlapping themes of active research: scholarship on chronotopes and soundscapes exploring processes that reconfigure time and place; work on subject creation focusing on voice, emotion, intersubjectivity, and listening; and scholarship on the social dimensions of object creation, including technological mediation, authentication, and circulation. I conclude by discussing future directions in research on language-music and the promise such work offers of furthering the call to broaden anthropology's holism while loosening adherence to its text-centered practices.

anthropology
Progress of International Music Geography Research and Its Implication for China

HE Jinliao,CHEN Yifei,LI Wei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.18306/dlkxjz.2024.05.013

2024-01-01

Abstract:Music geography is an interdisciplinary subject between geography,musicology,culture studies,and other disciplines.Compared with the well-established music geography in Western countries,music geography in China is still in the embryonic phase.This study attempted to provide a literature review for the progress of music geography research outside China by having a close look at its origin,development paths,essential debates,frameworks,and approaches,based on an in-depth bibliometric analysis.First,this study found that international research on music geography has extended its scope from the perspective of cultural geography to an interdisciplinary discourse and received great attention from economic geography,political geography,and urban geography.Second,the core themes of international music geography research can be generally classified into five branches:music regions and cultural diffusion,industrial clusters and networks,temporal-spatial phenomena and influences of music performance,music-based identity and cultural politics,and music geography as a special urban soundscape.In terms of theories and approaches,international music geography research can be divided into four main branches:cultural geography,geopolitics,economic geography,and urban geography,which are respectively influenced by the non-representational theory of new cultural geography,popular geopolitics and the relational turn of economic geography,and other important trends.Lastly,this article proposed that there is a great necessity to pay more attention to music research by Chinese geographers as it serves as an ideal case and instrument to inquire into geographical issues such as local identity,authenticity,and sense of place,local-global connections,creative production networks,temporary projects,urban planning,and social well-being.
When the local encounters the global: aesthetic conflicts in the Chinese traditional music world

Jiaxuan Yu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s40711-022-00169-y

2022-06-25

The Journal of Chinese Sociology

Abstract:Abstract Through a case study of the Chinese traditional music world, this study explores how artists in different specializations within an art world working on an indigenous art form make sense of divergent aesthetics. By adopting both Becker’s (Art worlds: 25th anniversary edition, updated and expanded, University of California Press, Berkeley, 2008) view of art worlds as substantially existing communities shared by artistic individuals and Bourdieu’s (Poetics 12(4–5):311–356, 1983) emphasis on artistic divergences stemming from broader social structures, I build a theoretical framework regarding how implicit aesthetic conflicts coexist with explicit collaborations in an art world. Under the impact of cultural globalization, the Chinese traditional music world’s conventions have experienced a historical revolution. Since then, music performers enact frames to defend the aesthetics that they consider “traditional” that emphasize stability in terms of the musical content but that have highly idiosyncratic styles of performance. However, other types of musicians—namely those involved in composing, conducting, theoretical research—are more likely to enact frames defending aesthetics that express a willingness to “Westernize” based on their understandings and emphasize on innovation in terms of musical content and systematic and routinized styles of performance. Their framings shape their different reactions to their art world’s conventions. By analyzing this process, I show how local–global dynamics constitute aesthetic conflicts in an art world that is often considered highly local and traditional.

sociology
The Harmless Drudge: Defining Ethnomusicology

Nettl Bruno,Yuan-zhe ZHENG

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1674-2338.2007.03.013

2007-01-01

Abstract:This essay talked about the multiplicity of the definitions of ethnomusicology,the different ways of defining a discipline,the history of the term "ethnomusicology",the principal activities of ethnomusicologists,and the kinds of people who eventually find themselves in this field. Beyond these,the author tried to give a two-pronged definition that is central to this book,and should like to tie it to four areas of belief: 1) Ethnomusicology is the study of music in culture;2) Ethnomusicology is the study of the world's musics from a comparative and relativistic perspective;3)Principally,ethnomusicology is study with the use of fieldwork;4) Ethnomusicology is the study of all of the musical manifestations of a society.
The Boundary of Chinese Music: A Cultural and Aesthetic Comparison Betweenpipaandguqin

Ivan Yifan Zou,Yaching Tsai,William Shi-Yuan Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1215/23290048-9965671

2022-01-01

Journal of Chinese Literature and Culture

Abstract:Reform and innovation toward the Western standards have been a perennial theme in the modern history of Chinese music. However, reformers can be easily overwhelmed by various details, to the point that the most fundamental question, What is Chinese music?, is often obscured. In a sense, we have to define the boundary of Chinese music to determine what new elements should be integrated and what traditional features should be preserved. Chinese music is a highly diverse and complex system, yet traditional Chinese culture emphasizes the importance of homogeneity over heterogeneity due to the constant need for political unity and demand of a single market. However, cultural identity cannot be constructed by homogeneity alone since the boundary of culture can only be best identified when examining its heterogeneity. Pipa and guqin, which represent Chinese musical cultures under significant and little Western influence, respectively, provide an ideal window through which the boundary of Chinese music might be delineated. By discussing the aesthetic pursuits and evolutionary paths that are distinct between the two instruments, the article aims to initiate a small step toward a better understanding of how Chinese music is indeed a highly complex and heterogeneous system in which various musical cultures, despite their distinct origins, can come into contact, interact, fuse, and eventually achieve the state of "unity in diversity."
The Boundary of Chinese Music: A Cultural and Aesthetic Comparison between Pipa and Guqin

Ivan Yifan Zou,Yaching Tsai,William Shi-Yuan Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1215/23290048-9965671

2022-11-01

Journal of Chinese Literature and Culture

Abstract:Abstract Reform and innovation toward the Western standards have been a perennial theme in the modern history of Chinese music. However, reformers can be easily overwhelmed by various details, to the point that the most fundamental question, What is Chinese music?, is often obscured. In a sense, we have to define the boundary of Chinese music to determine what new elements should be integrated and what traditional features should be preserved. Chinese music is a highly diverse and complex system, yet traditional Chinese culture emphasizes the importance of homogeneity over heterogeneity due to the constant need for political unity and demand of a single market. However, cultural identity cannot be constructed by homogeneity alone since the boundary of culture can only be best identified when examining its heterogeneity. Pipa and guqin, which represent Chinese musical cultures under significant and little Western influence, respectively, provide an ideal window through which the boundary of Chinese music might be delineated. By discussing the aesthetic pursuits and evolutionary paths that are distinct between the two instruments, the article aims to initiate a small step toward a better understanding of how Chinese music is indeed a highly complex and heterogeneous system in which various musical cultures, despite their distinct origins, can come into contact, interact, fuse, and eventually achieve the state of “unity in diversity.”
The civilizational return of Eastern “Rites and Music” and Western “Ethics” in modern music education

Li Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1590/0101-3173.2024.v47.n4.e0240090

2024-01-01

Trans/Form/Ação

Abstract:Abstract: Civilization is a symbol of culture, and only music education with the spirit of civilization has the core of culture. To meet the needs of the times and promote the reform of the educational system, this study analyzes the Eastern rites and music civilization, and Western ethical civilization. The similarities and differences between them were compared. It was found that both affirm the moral-emotional-aesthetic value of music, but they consider the internal and external nature of its role different. The philosophical foundations of the music education system in modern society are analyzed, and the current state of music education is reflected. Aiming at the problems of lack of subjectivity, lack of understanding and lack of musical identity in music education, the study proposes an innovative path for modern music education in the way of the return of the civilizations of oriental “rites and music” and western “ethics,” i.e., resetting the norms of the musical grammatical behavior, penetrating the humanistic connotations and defining the position of subjectivity.
Perspectives on Music, Sound and Musicology

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-78451-5

2021-01-01

Abstract:This book gathers a set of works highlighting significant advances in the areas of music and sound. They report on innovative music technologies, acoustics, findings in musicology, new perspectives and techniques for composition, sound design and sound synthesis, and methods for music education and therapy. Further, they cover interesting topics at the intersection between music and computing, design and social sciences. Chapters are based on extended and revised versions of the best papers presented during the 6th and 7th editions of EIMAD– Meeting of Research in Music, Arts and Design, held in 2020 and 2021, respectively, at the School of Applied Arts in Castelo Branco, Portugal. All in all, this book provides music researchers, educators and professionals with authoritative information about new trends and techniques, and a source of inspiration for future research, practical developments, and for establishing collaboration between experts from different fields.
Half Sound, Half Philosophy

Jing Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5040/9781501333514

2021-01-01

Abstract:From the late 1990s until today, China’s sound practice has been developing in an increasingly globalized socio-political-aesthetic milieu, receiving attentions and investments from the art world, music industry and cultural institutes, with nevertheless, its unique acoustic philosophy remaining silent. This book traces the history of sound practice from contemporary Chinese visual art back in the 1980s, to electronic music, which was introduced as a target of critique in the 1950s, to electronic instrument building fever in the late 1970s and early 1980s, and to the origins of both academic and nonacademic electronic and experimental music activities. This expansive tracing of sound in the arts resonates with another goal of this book, to understand sound and its artistic practice through notions informed by Chinese qi-cosmology and qi-philosophy, including notions of resonance, shanshui (mountains-waters), huanghu (elusiveness and evasiveness), and distributed monumentality and anti-monumentality. By turning back to deep history to learn about the meaning and function of sound and listening in ancient China, the book offers a refreshing understanding of the British sinologist Joseph Needham’s statement that “Chinese acoustics is acoustics of qi.” and expands existing conceptualization of sound art and contemporary music at large.
Sounding Out Normative and Colour-Blind Listening in Acoustic Ecology

Nimalan Yoganathan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3138/cjc.2022-0025

2022-09-01

Canadian Journal of Communication

Abstract:Background: The field of acoustic ecology emerged from Simon Fraser University in the late 1960s during which time R. Murray Schafer and the World Soundscape Project studied everyday soundscapes and the rise of urban noise. While it was an innovative approach to understanding the relationship between humans and their environments, it reproduced the dominant frameworks of this period. Analysis: This article argues that contemporary acoustic ecology discourse continues to frame noise, silence, and urban acoustic design through a white normative and colour-blind listening framework. This article examines dominant authorship and citation practices within leading journals that publish soundscape literature as well as sound mapping practices. Conclusion: After also surveying seldom-cited soundscape research that interrogates the environmental listening and sound-making practices of BIPOC and marginalized communities, the article concludes that there is a need for contemporary soundscape research to incorporate more intersectional and decolonial modes of environmental listening.
Music Against the Challenges of Digital Society

Boris V. Markov,Dmitriy A. Yarochkin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.17516/1997-1370-0762

2021-06-01

Abstract:The aim of the article is to separate the concepts of musicology, music anthropology, music, and instrumentalism. This very division and reflection of the interrelations of concepts provide a starting point for a detailed study of the problems of musical instrumentalism. The article is methodological in nature. It contains a number of important settings that are necessary for the anthropological analysis of music. The Central theoretical explanation of the article is the separation of musical anthropology and the anthropology of music. For this purpose, a number of tasks, namely, the definition of the theoretical fields of musical anthropology and the anthropology of music, and the disclosure of the role of music in traditional and modern society are proposed. The concept of musical action is introduced. Solving these problems allows to give a more complete analysis of the relationship between a person and music. It is this problem that becomes the main problem in the music media mainstream, where popular music is used as a way of producing moods and experiences. Music becomes a particularly valuable commodity in a networked society, which is made not so much for the purpose of incorporating into the values of high culture but to control the behavior of people in the music market. In addition to commercialization, music is becoming an effective political technology that provides consensus among voters. In this regard, there is a cultural problem, how high art in general and music, in particular, can preserve its traditional purpose – to promote humanization
Soundscape composition: the convergence of ethnography and acousmatic music

John Levack Drever

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/s1355771802001048

2002-04-01

Organised Sound

Abstract:Despite roots in acoustic ecology and soundscape studies, the practice and study of soundscape composition is often grouped with, or has grown out of the acousmatic music tradition. This can be observed in the positioning of soundscape compositions juxtaposed with acousmatic music compositions in concert programmes, CD compilations and university syllabuses. Not only does this positioning inform how soundscape composition is listened to, but also how it is produced, sonically and philosophically. If the making and presenting of representations of environmental sound is of fundamental concern to the soundscape artist, then it must be addressed. As this methodological issue is outside of previous musical concerns, to this degree, we must look to other disciplines that are primarily engaged with the making of representation, and that have thoroughly questioned what it is to make and present representations in the world today. One such discipline is ethnography. After briefly charting the genesis of soundscape composition and its underlying principles and motivations, the rest of the paper will present and develop one perspective, that of considering soundscape composition as ethnography.

English Else
Sharing uncertainty: Music in humanistic and scientific understandings

Ian Cross

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/10298649231197388

2023-09-08

Musicae Scientiae

Abstract:Musicae Scientiae, Ahead of Print. The idea that science either can or does provide definitive ways of understanding music arose in the middle of the past century and almost immediately stimulated severe criticism, much of it from a perspective that came to elevate culture to the status to which science had been assumed to presume. It can be suggested that by the turn of the millennium the terms of this debate had begun to fragment. The idea of a positivistic science as the incremental accrual of a body of facts increasingly approximating to monadic truth was replaced by ideas of the sciences as multiple epistemologies that are mutually irreducible but somehow commensurable, as a set of related processes that result in highly instrumental yet still provisional bodies of knowledge. Simultaneously, the idea of culture as a stable and clearly identifiable set of features and practices was undermined by the realization of the political nature of the term and its applications—by a growing understanding of processes of cultural fluidity, hybridity, value, and identity formation—while the concept of the musical work was contested, as was the very idea of music as a discrete domain of thought and behavior. We have thus been left with a field of uncertainties that is too often used as an interdisciplinary battleground rather than as a meeting place to examine and negotiate the ideas and ontological commitments of our own and others' disciplines. These uncertainties sometimes appear in plain sight but more often constitute implicit elements of disciplinary practice. We need to ensure that we negotiate encounters between disciplinary practices and commitments with our uncertainties in plain sight to develop mutual understanding across the broad worlds of humanistic and scientific research.

psychology, experimental
The evolution of music in the fusion of Chinese and Western cultures: an analysis of historical cultural Context and social and political significance

Fangge Du

DOI: https://doi.org/10.62051/m45bdm42

2024-08-29

Abstract:Following the track of communication between Chinese and western music since ancient times, this paper focuses on the characteristics of music fusion in different times and its hidden social motivations. First, this paper examines the origins of ancient Chinese and Western musical exchanges, such as the Silk Road, which contributed to the collision and integration of cultural ideas; Then, the spotlight turns to modern times, especially during the 20th century, in the face of the expansion of Western cultural forces, how the Chinese musical territory absorbs and transforms the essence of Western music, and this change has a profound impact on the Chinese classical music system. Then, under the blue picture of global integration, the symphonic and symbiotic phenomenon of Chinese and Western music is explored, and its value and significance in building a multi-musical ecological chain is analyzed. The role of music as a tender agent of national diplomacy, a melodic cornerstone of national identity construction, and a resonant voice of social movements is also explored in detail. Through case studies, such as the compositions, movements and music festivals of outstanding musicians, the power of music to transcend geographical and cultural barriers and promote understanding and harmonious coexistence among all ethnic groups is revealed. The interweaving of Chinese and western music is not only a superficial exchange of artistic forms, but also a reflection of profound cultural dialogue and social pulsation. It not only adds new blood to the connotation of music art, but also provides an innovative perspective to ease the cultural friction in the process of globalization. Future research should deepen the exploration of the integration of Chinese and Western music to promote global peace and development.
World music: deterritorializing place and identity

John Connell,Chris Gibson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1191/0309132504ph493oa

IF: 7.602

2004-06-01

Progress in Human Geography

Abstract:Music has been neglected in geography, yet the rise of ‘world music’ exemplifies the multiple ways in which places are constructed, commodified and contested. Music from distant and ‘exotic’ places has long entered the western canon, yet the pace of diffusion to the west accelerated with the rise of reggae and the marketing of Paul Simon's Graceland (1986), which pointed to the modification and transformation of distant, ‘other’ musics for western tastes and markets. Fusion and hybridity in musical styles emphasized both the impossibility of tracing authenticity in musical styles and the simultaneous exoticism and accessibility of distant musics. ‘Strategic inauthenticity’, romanticization and the fetishization of marginality were central to the search for and marketing of purity and novelty: simplistic celebrations of geographical diversity and remoteness. The formal arrival of world music in 1987 was as a marketing category with commerce and culture entangled and inseparable, in a form of appropriation for western, cosmopolitan audiences. Yet, for musicians, world music was an expressive project, which created identities that fused the local and global, traditional and modern. For some, international success required artistic compromise, essentialized identities and the resources of transnational companies. Others simply resisted categorization. The expansion of world music exemplifies the deterritorialization of cultures and emphasizes how the rise of a particular cultural commodity (world music) is primarily a commercial phenomenon, but could not have occurred without the construction and contestation of discourses of place and otherness.

geography
Soundscape Composition as Global Music: Electroacoustic music as soundscape

Barry Truax

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/s1355771808000149

2008-06-25

Organised Sound

Abstract:Abstract The author covers the background of soundscape composition, as initiated by the World Soundscape Project at Simon Fraser University, and soundscape documentation as an activity that is being increasingly practised worldwide. Today there are two striking manifestations of this work: the increasing globalisation of the electroacoustic community, and the increasing sophistication of digital techniques applied to soundscape composition. In addition, the tradition of listening to environmental soundscapes as if they were music is inverted to suggest listening to electroacoustic music as if it were soundscape. What analytical tools and insights would result? The theoretical concepts introduced in soundscape studies and acoustic communication are summarised and applied first to media and digital gaming environments, noting the extensions of both their sound worlds and the related listening attitudes they provoke in terms of analytical and distracted listening. Traditional approaches to acousmatic and soundscape analysis are compared for their commonalities and differences, the latter being mainly their relative balance of attention towards inner and outer complexity. The types of electroacoustic music most amenable to a soundscape based analysis are suggested, along with brief examples of pieces to which such analysis might be directed.
Thai musicology in context: epistemic disparities in Thai and western ways of knowing Thai music

John Garzoli,Tharanat Hin-on

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/17411912.2023.2236630

2023-08-04

Ethnomusicology Forum

Abstract:Relatively little has been published in English about dontri Thai (Thai classical music) and due to the absence of Thai scholars from English language musicological scholarship, most of what has been published was written by non-Thai scholars who have relied upon terms and concepts developed for explaining music with roots in the European tradition. The importation of extrinsic categories conceals indigenous explanatory models and blocks paths connecting Thai musical performance and thought to other areas of Thai culture and social life. This article frames the silence of Thai voices and their ways of knowing as the epistemological dimension of the colonising enterprise, the effects of which have made their way into Thai universities where they have transformed intellectual life and dontri Thai pedagogy. The disciplinary reorientation suggested here aims towards a pluralist model of musicological thought and method. This will open a space for different ways of musical knowing, creating, and theorising to enter from where they may decentre and reshape Western musicological discourse and practice. A rethink of musicology will help align its disciplinary goals with the aims of addressing equality of representation and allow unheard Thai voices to explain their own music in their own terms.
The Sound of the Study of “Literature”: A Survey of Issues of Sound in Ancient Liteary Texts and Studies on Texts

Chen Yinchi

2012-01-01

Abstract:Literature develops from the oral to the written, and ancient texts were not only written for silent study reading but also for sound interpretive reading. The paper exemplifies the different aspects of sound in Chinese classical literary texts, with particular attention to Tongcheng School’s investigations into the sound issues in Qing Dynasty. The paper proceeds to delineate the possible relations between the sound issues in prose and in verse, and hopes to provide an example to the interplay between genres.
Intercultural music: Creation and interpretation

Peter Dunbar-Hall

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/08145857.2007.10416601

2007-01-01

Musicology Australia

Abstract:Intercultural Music: Creation and Interpretation is a collection of refereed papers from the conference component of the 2006 Aurora New Music Festival, held at the University of Western Sydney. The editors are keen to point out that the definition of ‚intercultural‘ invoked is wide and that the collection presents some awkwardnesses. This is notably in discussion of the problems associated with representing musical creativity and performance as research, a topic that will resonate with tertiary music educators in various locations around the world who are forced into positions of justifying their activities as research for the purpose of securing funding for their institutions. The composition/performance-as-research problem arises within this text where the musical works discussed exhibit some degree of interculturality—even if this is not the basis of the composition/performance- as-research issue—so so some mind juggling is required to fit individual discussions under the book—s title. That said, the majority of essays in Intercultural Music do address cultural interaction in music, and authors who take on the composition/performance-as-research topic, for example, Diana Blom and Michael Atherton, provide useful models of how preparation for performance or the processes of composition (including improvisation) can be packaged and documented as research.

From Music to Sound-Issues Concerning the Boundaries of Ethnomusicology

Music, Language, and Texts: Sound and Semiotic Ethnography

Progress of International Music Geography Research and Its Implication for China

When the local encounters the global: aesthetic conflicts in the Chinese traditional music world

The Harmless Drudge: Defining Ethnomusicology

The Boundary of Chinese Music: A Cultural and Aesthetic Comparison Betweenpipaandguqin

The Boundary of Chinese Music: A Cultural and Aesthetic Comparison between Pipa and Guqin

The civilizational return of Eastern “Rites and Music” and Western “Ethics” in modern music education

Perspectives on Music, Sound and Musicology

Half Sound, Half Philosophy

Sounding Out Normative and Colour-Blind Listening in Acoustic Ecology

Music Against the Challenges of Digital Society

Soundscape composition: the convergence of ethnography and acousmatic music

Sharing uncertainty: Music in humanistic and scientific understandings

The evolution of music in the fusion of Chinese and Western cultures: an analysis of historical cultural Context and social and political significance

World music: deterritorializing place and identity

Soundscape Composition as Global Music: Electroacoustic music as soundscape

Thai musicology in context: epistemic disparities in Thai and western ways of knowing Thai music

The Sound of the Study of “Literature”: A Survey of Issues of Sound in Ancient Liteary Texts and Studies on Texts

Intercultural music: Creation and interpretation