Economics Imperialism: Concept and Constraints
Igor Douven,Maarten Janssen,Ben Fine,Zbigniew Hockuba,Aki Lehtinen,Andrea Salanti,Warren Samuels,Christian Sartorius,Timo Tammi,Ricardo Tolipan,Jack Vromen,Ulrich Witt,Jesus Zamora Bonilla
2008-01-01
Abstract:The paper seeks to offer [1] an explication of a concept of economics imperialism, focusing on its epistemic aspects; and [2] criteria for its normative assessment. In regard to [1], the defining notion is that of explanatory unification across disciplinary boundary. As to [2], three kinds of constraints are proposed. An ontological constraint requires an increased degree of ontological unification in contrast to mere derivational unification. An axiological constraint derives from variation in the perceived relative significance of the facts explained. An epistemological constraint requires strong fallibilism acknowledging a particularly severe epistemic uncertainty and proscribing against over-confident arrogance. Acknowledgements Ancestors of this paper have been presented at the University of Helsinki, April 2007; Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, October 2000; Lund University, Sweden, October 2000; the University of Veracruz at Xalapa, Mexico, June 2000; Erasmus Institute for Philosophy and Economics, Rotterdam, March 2000; the Max Planck Institute in Jena, Germany, February 2000; the Academy of Finland workshop on The Expansionism of Economics in Current Social Science, Joensuu, Finland, August 1999; the conference on Progress in the Study of Economic Evolution, Ancona, Italy, May 1999; and the workshop on The Scope of Economic Theory, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, March 1998. Thanks for helpful comments go to the audiences of these events, and in particular to Igor Douven, Maarten Janssen, Ben Fine, Zbigniew Hockuba, Aki Lehtinen, Andrea Salanti, Warren Samuels, Christian Sartorius, Timo Tammi, Ricardo Tolipan, Jack Vromen, Ulrich Witt, Jesus Zamora Bonilla, and Petri Ylikoski. A Portuguese translation of a much earlier version has appeared in a Brazilian journal as “Imperialismo da Economia: conceitos e restrições”, Economica, 2, 3/2000, 5-36.