Application and Comparative Analysis of Four Conceptual Hydrological Models for Upper Reach of Heihe River Basin

HE Siwei,NAN Zhuotong,WANG Shugong,DING Yongjian
2012-01-01
Abstract:Four popular conceptual hydrological models, namely Xianjiang model, HBV, TopModel and Sacramento model, were evaluated in this paper in terms of model structure and application performance in the upper reach of the Heihe River Basin, a typical inland river basin in the arid region of West China. This paper begins with theoretical comparisons between the four models from varied aspects including soil profile division, soil moisture content calculation, evapotranspiration estimation, disparity of runoff generation area, runoff generation mechanism, and infiltration mechanism. In combination with their applications in the upper reach of the Huaihe River Basin, the four models were evaluated based on their estimates of soil moisture content, evapotranspiration, runoff process prediction and runoff components. The applications in the Huaihe River Basin show that conceptual hydrological models are good at runoff simulation and incapable of accurate estimation of soil moisture content and evapotranspiration despite.They can only simulate the change trends of these two variables. Among the four, the HBV model is proven best in the case study with better simulation in the water-stress period regardless of a similar overall Nash-Sutcliffe coefficient for runoff simulation, as its model structure explicitly considers the characteristics of a watershed in arid and cold regions.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?