Time-Varying Preferences and SAD: Evidence from an Asset-Pricing Model

Mark J. Kamstra,Lisa A. Kramer,Maurice D. Levi,Tan Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1360976

2009-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:Download This Paper Open PDF in Browser Add Paper to My Library Share: Permalink Using these links will ensure access to this page indefinitely Copy URL Copy DOI

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Seasonally Varying Preferences: Theoretical Foundations for an Empirical Regularity

Mark J. Kamstra,Lisa A. Kramer,Maurice D. Levi,Tan Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1787762

2014-01-01

The Review of Asset Pricing Studies

Abstract:We investigate an asset pricing model with preferences cycling between high risk aversion and low EIS in fall/winter and the reverse in spring/summer. Calibrating to consumption data and allowing plausible preference parameter values, we produce returns that match observed equity and Treasury returns across the seasons: risky returns are higher and risk-free returns are lower or stable in fall/winter, and they reverse in spring/summer. Further, risky returns vary more than risk-free returns. A novel finding is that both EIS and risk aversion must vary seasonally to match observed returns. Further, the degree of necessary seasonal change in EIS is small.
Time-inconsistent preferences, investment and asset pricing

Bo Liu,Lei Lu,Congming Mu,Jinqiang Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econlet.2016.09.015

IF: 1.469

2016-01-01

Economics Letters

Abstract:In this paper, we present a production-based asset pricing model in which agents have time-inconsistent preferences. We find that the time-inconsistent preferences lead to under-investment, over-consumption, and higher interest rate. These variables are distorted more in the economy with naive agent than the economy with sophisticated agent. In particular, the sophisticated agent invests more and consumes less than the naive agent, but invests less and consumes more than the time-consistent agent. The interest rate in the sophisticated agent economy is lower than that in the naive agent economy, but higher than that in the time-consistent agent economy.
Time-Varying Risk Aversion and Dynamic Portfolio Allocation.

Haitao Li,Chongfeng Wu,Chunyang Zhou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1287/opre.2020.2095

IF: 2.7

2021-01-01

Operations Research

Abstract:Despite the overwhelming evidence of time-varying risk aversion documented in recent literature, standard dynamic portfolio theories often adopt an assumption of constant (relative) risk aversion due to analytical tractability. In “Time Varying Risk Aversion and Dynamic Portfolio Allocation,” Li et al. explicitly consider the implications of time-varying risk aversion for dynamic portfolio allocation under the framework of regime-switching models. An investor with regime-dependent utility exhibits a decreasing relative risk aversion (DRRA) and has higher risk aversion when a bear market regime is more likely in the future. They develop an efficient dynamic programming algorithm that overcomes the challenges imposed by regime-dependent preference in obtaining time-consistent portfolio policies. The empirical results show that VIX is an important predictor of regime shifts and that investors with regime-dependent risk aversion achieve better investment performance than those with constant risk aversion.
The Time Variation in Risk Appetite and Uncertainty

Geert Bekaert,Eric Engstrom,Nancy R. Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3069078

2017-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:We formulate a dynamic no-arbitrage asset pricing model for equities and corporate bonds, featuring time-varying risk aversion and economic uncertainty. The joint dynamics that we specify among asset-specific cash flows, macroeconomic fundamentals and risk aversion accommodate both heteroskedasticity and non-Gaussianity. As the main contribution, the model delivers measures of risk aversion and uncertainty at daily frequency. In addition, we find that variance risk premiums on equity are very informative about risk aversion, whereas credit spreads and corporate bond volatility are highly correlated with economic uncertainty. Our model-implied risk premiums outperform standard instruments for predicting excess returns on equity and corporate bonds. A financial proxy to economic uncertainty predicts output growth significantly and negatively.
Does sadness bring myopia: an intertemporal choice experiment with college students

Peng Lei,Hao Zhang,Wenyu Zheng,Luoyi Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1345951

IF: 3.8

2024-04-27

Frontiers in Psychology

Abstract:Introduction: While economics often interprets individual intertemporal choice preferences through the rationality assumption of utility maximization, the reality is that as emotional beings, individuals' preferences for intertemporal behavior are much more diverse and inconsistent. Prior research has predominantly focused on positive or negative emotions based on prospect theory, such as anxiety, anger, disgust, and depression. However, there has been relatively little research on how sadness affects individuals' preferences for immediate and future rewards. Methods: In this study, 170 college students are recruited as participants, and their emotions are primed with a video before engaging in an intertemporal task. Covariance analysis and logit regression model are established to examine the main and interactive effects of sadness on individuals' immediate reward preferences. Results: The findings reveal that sadness led individuals to prefer smaller immediate rewards, demonstrating a more myopic behavioral pattern, but didn't affect time discount rate. As the reward baseline increases, sadness's impact on immediate reward preferences is more pronounced, exacerbating individuals' myopic behavior. Discussion: In conclusion, these findings underscore the importance of considering emotional states in economic decision-making models and suggest avenues for future research to explore the complex dynamics of emotions and intertemporal choices.

psychology, multidisciplinary
Is there time discounting for risk premium?

Tal Shavit,Mosi Rosenboim

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/jeab.139

2015-03-01

Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior

Abstract:Individuals with a higher subjective discount rate concentrate more on the present and delay is more significant for them. However, when a risky asset is delayed, not only is the outcome delayed but also the risk. In this paper, we suggest a new, two-stage experimental method with real monetary incentives that allows us to distinguish between the effect of the risk and the effect of the time when pricing a risky asset. We show that when individuals have greater preference for the present, their risk aversion for a risky asset realized in the future decreases. We argue that the effect of the risk for future asset is lower for individuals with higher time preference because they discount not only the outcome but also the risks.

behavioral sciences,psychology, experimental, biological
The competitions of time-varying and constant loadings in asset pricing models: empirical evidence and agent-based simulations

Hung-Wen Lin,Jing-Bo Huang,Kun-Ben Lin,Shu-Heng Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11403-021-00337-2

2021-11-24

Journal of Economic Interaction and Coordination

Abstract:Under two frameworks of cross-section and time-series factors, we implement asset pricing models to dissect the abnormal returns in the Chinese stock market. Our findings indicate that the model using the earnings-to-price factor outperforms the model using the book-to-market factor in the framework of cross-section factors. Moreover, we further compare the time-varying loadings with constant loadings in the asset pricing models. Existing research has implied the outperformance of time-varying loadings in the US market. However, we consider the effects of backdoor listings in the Chinese stock market. Our evidence documents that the time-varying loading factor model cannot perfectly surpass the constant loading model. Our agent-based simulations indicate that such a finding originates from the static collective behaviors and stable beliefs of the Chinese traders.

economics
Utility Indifference Pricing: A Time Consistent Approach

Traian A. Pirvu,Huayue Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/1350486x.2012.700575

2013-09-01

Applied Mathematical Finance

Abstract:This article considers the optimal portfolio selection problem in a dynamic multi-period stochastic framework with regime switching. The risk preferences are of exponential (CARA) type with an absolute coefficient of risk aversion that changes with the regime. The market model is incomplete and there are two risky assets: tradable and non-tradable. In this context, the optimal investment strategies are time inconsistent. Consequently, the subgame perfect equilibrium strategies are considered. The utility indifference ask price of a contingent claim written on the risky assets is computed through an indifference valuation algorithm. By running numerical experiments, we examine how this price varies in response to changes in model parameters.

English Else
Why Stocks May Disappoint

Andrew Ang,Geert Bekaert,Jun Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.216850

2000-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:Recently much progress has been made in developing optimal portfolio choice models accomodating time-varying opportunity sets, but unless investors are unreasonably risk averse, optimal holdings include unreasonably large equity positions. One reason is that most studies assume investors behave as expected utility maximizers with power utility. In this article, we provide a formal treatment of both static and dynamic portfolio choice using the Disappointment Aversion preferences of Gul (1991). While different from the Kahneman-Tversky (1979) loss aversion utility, these preferences imply asymmetric aversion to gains versus losses and are consistent with the tendency of some people to like lottery-type gambles but dislike stock investments. By calibrating a number of data generating processes to actual US data on stock and bond returns, we find very reasonable portfolios for moderately disappointment averse investors with utility functions exhibiting low curvature. Disappointment aversion preferences affect intertemporal hedging demands and the state dependence of asset allocation in such a way as to not be replicable by standard expected utility functions with higher curvature. Furthermore, it is easy to reconcile the large equity premium observed in the data with disappointment aversion utility of low curvature and reasonable disappointment.
Time Varying Risk Aversion: An Application to Energy Hedging

John Cotter,Jim Hanly

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1103.5968

2011-03-30

Risk Management

Abstract:Risk aversion is a key element of utility maximizing hedge strategies; however, it has typically been assigned an arbitrary value in the literature. This paper instead applies a GARCH-in-Mean (GARCH-M) model to estimate a time-varying measure of risk aversion that is based on the observed risk preferences of energy hedging market participants. The resulting estimates are applied to derive explicit risk aversion based optimal hedge strategies for both short and long hedgers. Out-of-sample results are also presented based on a unique approach that allows us to forecast risk aversion, thereby estimating hedge strategies that address the potential future needs of energy hedgers. We find that the risk aversion based hedges differ significantly from simpler OLS hedges. When implemented in-sample, risk aversion hedges for short hedgers outperform the OLS hedge ratio in a utility based comparison.
Diverging Effects of Subjective Prospect Values of Uncertain Time and Money

Kun Gao,Ying Yang,Xiaobo Qu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.commtr.2021.100007

2021-01-01

Communications in Transportation Research

Abstract:Studies from behavioral economics show that the subjective prospect value of money has diminishing sensitivity to losses/gains, represented by an S-shape, and this has been applied in representing the subjective prospect value of time in many transportation studies such as travel behavior modeling and network equilibrium. In this study, we demonstrate that the prospect value of time has an increasing sensitivity to losses/gains and can be represented by an Ϩ-shape, which contrasts that of money. We further explain the rationality of this surprising finding based on psychological and behavioral theories and discuss extensive practical implications. The correlations between sensitivities to gains and losses in terms of magnitude are revealed as well to shed light on potential underlying correlated behavioral principles. Substantial loss-aversion features are observed in the empirical analysis, supporting endowment effects. Implications of the findings on decision-making and other areas that utilize time as a key indicator have been discussed. The findings may revolutionize many research areas that utilize time as a key indicator such as transportation engineering.
Endogenous time-varying risk aversion and asset returns

Michele Berardi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00191-015-0435-3

Abstract:Stylized facts about statistical properties for short horizon returns in financial markets have been identified in the literature, but a satisfactory understanding for their manifestation is yet to be achieved. In this work, we show that a simple asset pricing model with representative agent is able to generate time series of returns that replicate such stylized facts if the risk aversion coefficient is allowed to change endogenously over time in response to unexpected excess returns under evolutionary forces. The same model, under constant risk aversion, would instead generate returns that are essentially Gaussian. We conclude that an endogenous time-varying risk aversion represents a very parsimonious way to make the model match real data on key statistical properties, and therefore deserves careful consideration from economists and practitioners alike.
Make Hay While The Sun Shines: An Empirical Study of Maximum Price, Regret and Trading Decisions

Julia Brettschneider,Giovanni Burro,Vicky Henderson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/jeea/jvae028

IF: 4.3013

2024-03-29

Journal of the European Economic Association

Abstract:Abstract Time-constant trading thresholds are optimal for a large class of preferences and asset price dynamics, including Expected Utility and the S-shaped reference-dependent utility of Prospect Theory. Such thresholds imply selling stocks at the maximum price since purchase. We use a large discount brokerage dataset containing US households’ trading records between 1991 and 1996 to document that in 31.6% of cases the stocks sold for a gain are sold on the day when the maximum since purchase occurs. However, not all stocks are sold at a maximum since purchase and the propensity to sell changes depending on how far in time and price the stock is with respect to this past maximum. We find that the propensity to sell initially increases as the price is closer to the past maximum but it then decreases when the price gets in the closest region to the past maximum, leading to an inverse U-shape; and that investors are less likely to sell a gain, the further away in time the maximum price occurred. Studying the joint effect of price and time distance, we find that the propensity to sell is highest at low time distance and high price distance from the maximum since purchase. We relate these findings to regret, belief updating, and attention.

economics
Ambiguity, Risk, and Asset Returns in Continuous Time

Zengjing Chen,Larry Epstein

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-0262.00337

IF: 6.1

2002-07-01

Econometrica

Abstract:Models of utility in stochastic continuous–time settings typically assume that beliefs are represented by a probability measure, hence ruling out a priori any concern with ambiguity. This paper formulates a continuous–time intertemporal version of multiple–priors utility, where aversion to ambiguity is admissible. In a representative agent asset market setting, the model delivers restrictions on excess returns that admit interpretations reflecting a premium for risk and a separate premium for ambiguity.

economics,social sciences, mathematical methods,mathematics, interdisciplinary applications,statistics & probability
THE SPIRIT OF CAPITALISM, NON-EXPECTED UTILITY AND ASSET PRICING

YH Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/s0252-9602(17)30524-6

1999-01-01

Acta Mathematica Scientia

Abstract:This paper investigates testable restrictions on the time-series behavior of consumption and asset returns implied by a representative agent model with the spirit of capitalism in which intertemporal preference is represented by a utility function that generalizes conventional, time-additive, expected utility. In the recursive structure of preference, the author examines the implication for cosumptions, portfolio holdings, and stock-market prices when investors accumulate wealth not only for the sake of consumption but also for wealth-induced social status. When investors care about relative social status, the propensity to consume and risk-taking behavior will depend on social standards, and stock prices will be volatible. Hence, the spirit of capitalism seems to be a driving force behind stock-market volatility and economic growth. Because the elasticity df substitution and the coefficient of relative risk aversion are independent and the spirit of capitalism is introduced, the equity premium puzzle can be partially explained in the model.
Countercyclical Risk Aversion: Evidence from 10 Million Auto Insurance Transactions in China

Huafeng Jason Chen,Yinglu Deng,Pengfei Li,Hao Zhou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3555699

2020-01-01

Abstract:A fundamental idea in modern asset pricing is that risk aversion may be time varying and countercyclical (Campbell and Cochrane 1999). Existing evidence is scant and based mostly on experimental or survey data. We aim to test this key assumption using a large panel of real-world transaction data. Risk aversion is imputed from Chinese auto insurance policies, including 10 million transactions from 2011 to 2017 and representing the entire population of 200 million auto insurance policies in China. We find that individuals' risk aversion is indeed time varying and countercyclical.
Evaluating Asset Pricing Models in Absence of Arbitrage: Econometric Approach and Empirical Applications

Yuewu Xu,Haitao Li,Xiaoyan Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.891125

2005-01-01

Abstract:We develop asset pricing tests that explicitly require that a true asset pricing model has to be arbitrage free, i.e., its stochastic discount factor has to be strictly positive. The no-arbitrage restriction is especially important in applications that involve dynamic trading strategies and derivatives. One prominent example is performance evaluation of actively managed portfolios, such as mutual funds and hedge funds. Empirical results show that the no-arbitrage restriction makes significant differences in asset pricing tests involving either the traditional Fama-French size and book-to-market portfolios or hedge fund style portfolios. Ignoring the no-arbitrage restriction, we reach the misleading conclusion that certain models can satisfactorily price both sets of assets. However, these models are overwhelmingly rejected by our tests because their stochastic discount factors take negative values with high probabilities. The no-arbitrage restriction also leads to better identified parameters, better behaved models, and more insights on potential sources of model misspecifications.
Study of Asset Pricing:A New Advancement Based on loss Aversion,Catching up With the Joneses and the Formation of the Habit

Yan ZOU,Ju-e GUO

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1007-3221.2008.01.024

2008-01-01

Abstract:For advancing the research of the asset pricing theory and interpreting the important market anomalies more,according to the introduction of the heterogeneity supposition of the investors,this paper constructs an utility function whose investor preferences are jointly decided by the formation of the habit,catching up with the Jones and loss aversion.Moreover,based on the more actual utility function,we develop a new consumption-based asset pricing model which can interpret the anomalies well.In addition,the pricing equations of the returns of assets of the model is derived via the Euler equation.Making use of the pricing equations,we can expect to explain the important anomalies such as equity premium puzzle,volatility puzzle and risk-free rate puzzle.It is proved that the key of settling the problems such as equity premium is the introduction of the reasonable behavior preferences.
Asset Pricing with Spatial Interaction

Steven Kou,Xianhua Peng,Haowen Zhong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2016.2627

IF: 5.4

2018-01-01

Management Science

Abstract:We propose a spatial capital asset pricing model and a spatial arbitrage pricing theory (S-APT) that extend the classical asset pricing models by incorporating spatial interaction. We then apply the S-APT to study the comovements of eurozone stock indices (by extending the Fama–French factor model to regional stock indices) and the futures contracts on S&P/Case–Shiller Home Price Indices; in both cases, spatial interaction is significant and plays an important role in explaining cross-sectional correlation.The e-companion is available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2016.2627 .This paper was accepted by Neng Wang, finance.
Procrastination and intertemporal consumption: A three-period extension of the CAPM with irrational agents

Helga Habis

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.frl.2024.105325

IF: 9.848

2024-04-11

Finance Research Letters

Abstract:In this paper, we investigate the capital asset pricing model (CAPM) derived from a three-period general equilibrium model incorporating time-inconsistent preferences. We define and consider two types of agents, i.e. they can be either sophisticated or naive. Sophisticated agents take into account their potentially changing future preferences when making a decision. Naive agents, on the other hand, do not anticipate this issue and their related self-control problems when they plan the consumption path. We demonstrate that the derivation of the CAPM equation can be achieved even if the agents in the financial economy have time-inconsistent preferences.

business, finance

Time-Varying Preferences and SAD: Evidence from an Asset-Pricing Model

Seasonally Varying Preferences: Theoretical Foundations for an Empirical Regularity

Time-inconsistent preferences, investment and asset pricing

Time-Varying Risk Aversion and Dynamic Portfolio Allocation.

The Time Variation in Risk Appetite and Uncertainty

Does sadness bring myopia: an intertemporal choice experiment with college students

Is there time discounting for risk premium?

The competitions of time-varying and constant loadings in asset pricing models: empirical evidence and agent-based simulations

Utility Indifference Pricing: A Time Consistent Approach

Why Stocks May Disappoint

Time Varying Risk Aversion: An Application to Energy Hedging

Diverging Effects of Subjective Prospect Values of Uncertain Time and Money

Endogenous time-varying risk aversion and asset returns

Make Hay While The Sun Shines: An Empirical Study of Maximum Price, Regret and Trading Decisions

Ambiguity, Risk, and Asset Returns in Continuous Time

THE SPIRIT OF CAPITALISM, NON-EXPECTED UTILITY AND ASSET PRICING

Countercyclical Risk Aversion: Evidence from 10 Million Auto Insurance Transactions in China

Evaluating Asset Pricing Models in Absence of Arbitrage: Econometric Approach and Empirical Applications

Study of Asset Pricing:A New Advancement Based on loss Aversion,Catching up With the Joneses and the Formation of the Habit

Asset Pricing with Spatial Interaction

Procrastination and intertemporal consumption: A three-period extension of the CAPM with irrational agents