"Founder Generation-Kin Modes"and Business Performance:An Empirical Study Based on Chinese Family Listed Companies
Chan YANG,Xiao-gang HE,Rong-ci XU
DOI: https://doi.org/10.19616/j.cnki.bmj.2018.06.002
2018-01-01
Abstract:Founder generation will have a significant impact on the performance of family-owned enterprises, while there is no consensus that whether the influence is positive or negative. It's not an empirical issue whether the performance of family firm depends on founder's involving cooperate governance, as a matter of fact, the key constraint is that there are different portfolio models of the family business governance involving founder and there are significant differences in governance efficiency between different portfolio models. Based on Hamilton's kinship theory, this paper classifies "founder-couple mode", "founder-sibling mode""founder-offspring mode"into "founder generation-kin mode", and categorizes "founder-remote kin mode""founder-friend mode""founder-partner mode"as"founder generation-non kin mode". Compared with"founder generation-non kin mode", family members in the"founder generation-kin mode"have a high levels of altruism. Based on this classification, this paper raises the following research questions: Firstly, will "founder generation-kin mode"result in a better family firm performance than "founder generation-non kin mode"? Secondly, if the "founder generation-non-kin mode"is more efficient, what kind of factors will restrict its superiority? Thirdly, "founder generation-kin mode"could be divided into"founder-couple mode", "founder-sibling mode""founder-offspring mode", are there any difference in governance efficiency among different sub-mode? By utilizing the data of the family companies listed in the main board of Shanghai and Shenzhen stock exchange from 2007 to 2014, this paper gets the following conclusions:Firstly, compared with other combination modes, "founder generation-kin mode"could improve the performance of family-owned enterprises more significantly. This is largely because "founder generation-kin mode"could reduce agency problems and opportunism in the family with a higher level of altruism, which will promote the operating performance of family. Secondly, the impact of the "founder generation-kin mode " on the performance of family-owned enterprises is moderated by the external institutional environment. This means that in the less perfect institutional environment, "founder generation-kin mode"is more conducive to improve the operating performance of family-owned enterprises. With continuous improvement of the institutional environment, the additional advantages of "founder generation-kin mode"will gradually decrease and the effect of reducing agency costs will be replaced by standardized and effective system. On the contrary, in the absence of institutional environment, founder and kin grasping core control can effectively offset the agency problems that caused by the absence of the external institutional environment system. Thirdly, the impact of the"founder generation-kin mode"on the performance of family-owned enterprises is moderated by the speed of technology change. It means that in industries with faster technology changes, "founder generation-kin mode"is more conducive to improve the operating performance of family-owned enterprises. Complex and dynamic environment will further strengthen the positive effects of "founder generation-kin mode". The high level of altruism and strategic consistency deriving from"founder generation-kin mode"help companies not only make fast and effective decisions in the complex and dynamic environment, but also gain first-move advantage when facing opportunities. Fourthly, different sub-mode in the"founder generation-kin mode"have different impacts on the operating performance of family-owned enterprises. "Founder-couple mode"and"founder-sibling mode"will positively influence the performance of the family-owned enterprises, while"founder-offspring mode"could not promote the enterprise performance because of the cross-generational conflict in value and emotion. While "founder-offspring mode"could produce positive effects only in certain situations, which means that under the circumstance of a serious lack of external institutional environment and rapid technological change in the industry, cross-generation combination might improve the operating performance of family enterprises.