Clinical effects of a combination treatment with narrow-spectrum intense pulsed light and fractional carbon dioxide laser on hypertrophic scar pruritus
Yiqiu Zhang,Jiying Dong,Shen Wang,Min Yan,Min Yao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.1009-2587.2018.09.010
2018-01-01
Abstract:Objective To observe the effects of a combination treatment with narrow-spectrum intense pulsed light and fractional carbon dioxide laser on hvpertrophic scar pruritus in clinic.Methods A prospective randomized controlled study was conducted.A total of 90 patients with hypertrophic scars conforming to the inclusion criteria who were hospitalized in our ward from March to December 2017 were divided into combination treatment group and control group according to the random number table,with 45 patients in each group.For scar pruritus,patients in control group were treated twice by narrow-spectrum intense pulsed light with a one-month interval,while patients in combination treatment group were firstly treated by narrowspectrum intense pulsed light combined with fractional carbon dioxide laser once,and with narrow-spectrum intense pulsed light once one month later.Before and 3 months after treatment,scar pruritus was evaluated by the Visual Analogue Scale and the Four-item Itch Questionnaire,and the improvement of scar was assessed by photography.Three months after treatment,the treatment satisfaction of scar pruritus was self-rated by patients.Meanwhile,adverse effects were recorded during the procedures and follow-up periods.Data were processed with Chi-square test,paired t test,Wilcoxon rank-sum test,and Fisher's exact probability test.Results Before treatment,there was no statistically significant difference in scar pruritus degree evaluated by the Visual Analogue Scale and score distribution of scar pruritus location,extent,frequency,and sleep effect of the Four-item Itch Questionnaire between patients of two groups (Z =-1.08,-0.91,-0.03,-0.69,-1.49,P ＞ 0.05).Three months after treatment,there was reducing degree of scar pruritus of patients evaluated by the Visual Analogue Scale in control group or combination treatment group compared with before treatment within the same group (Z =-1.98,-4.65,P ＜0.05 orP ＜0.01),while the latter was more obvious than the former (Z =-2.14,P ＜0.05).There were reducing scores of scar pruritus extent and frequency of patients in control group,along with location,extent,frequency,and sleep effect of patients in combination treatment group compared with those before treatment within the same group (Z =-2.33,-2.34,-3.53,-4.96,-3.32,-4.84,P ＜0.05 orP ＜0.01).However,scores of scar pruritus location and sleep effect of patients in control group were similar to those before treatment within the same group (Z =-0.58,-1.34,P ＞0.05).The scores of scar pruritus location,extent,frequency,and sleep effect of patients were obviously lower in combination treatment group compared with controlgroup (Z =-2.09,-2.69,-1.99,-2.23,P ＜0.05 orP ＜0.01).It was much better of scar improvement of patients in combination treatment group compared with control group (Z =-4.00,P ＜0.01).The percentages of treatment satisfaction of scar pruritus of patients with 0,1％-25％,26％ -50％,51％-75％,76％-100％ were 0,2.2％ (1/45),17.8％ (8/45),48.9％ (22/45),and 31.1％ (14/45) respectively in combination treatment group,which were obviously better than 0,11.1％ (5/45),53.3％ (24/45),28.9％ (13/45),and 6.7％ (3/45) in control group (Z =-4.42,P ＜ 0.01).During the treatment and follow-up periods,the adverse effect ratio of patients in control group was 6.7％ (3/45),similar to 2.2％ (1/45) of combination treatment group (P ＞ 0.05).Conclusions The combination of narrow-spectrum intense pulsed light and fractional carbon dioxide laser can greatly reduce pruritus,improve effect of scar treatment,and bring higher patient satisfaction compared with narrowspectrum intense pulsed light alone in treating hypertrophic scar pruritus.Clinical trial registration Chinese Clinical Trial Registry,ChiCTR-ONH-17012350.