Abstract:PURPOSE: To assess the performance of two approaches to the system response matrix (SRM) calculation in pinhole single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) reconstruction.METHODS: Evaluation was performed using experimental data from a low magnification pinhole SPECT system that consisted of a rotating flat detector with a monolithic scintillator crystal. The SRM was computed following two approaches, which were based on Monte Carlo simulations (MC-SRM) and analytical techniques in combination with an experimental characterization (AE-SRM). The spatial response of the system, obtained by using the two approaches, was compared with experimental data. The effect of the MC-SRM and AE-SRM approaches on the reconstructed image was assessed in terms of image contrast, signal-to-noise ratio, image quality, and spatial resolution. To this end, acquisitions were carried out using a hot cylinder phantom (consisting of five fillable rods with diameters of 5, 4, 3, 2, and 1 mm and a uniform cylindrical chamber) and a custom-made Derenzo phantom, with center-to-center distances between adjacent rods of 1.5, 2.0, and 3.0 mm.RESULTS: Good agreement was found for the spatial response of the system between measured data and results derived from MC-SRM and AE-SRM. Only minor differences for point sources at distances smaller than the radius of rotation and large incidence angles were found. Assessment of the effect on the reconstructed image showed a similar contrast for both approaches, with values higher than 0.9 for rod diameters greater than 1 mm and higher than 0.8 for rod diameter of 1 mm. The comparison in terms of image quality showed that all rods in the different sections of a custom-made Derenzo phantom could be distinguished. The spatial resolution (FWHM) was 0.7 mm at iteration 100 using both approaches. The SNR was lower for reconstructed images using MC-SRM than for those reconstructed using AE-SRM, indicating that AE-SRM deals better with the projection noise than MC-SRM.CONCLUSIONS: The authors' findings show that both approaches provide good solutions to the problem of calculating the SRM in pinhole SPECT reconstruction. The AE-SRM was faster to create and handle the projection noise better than MC-SRM. Nevertheless, the AE-SRM required a tedious experimental characterization of the intrinsic detector response. Creation of the MC-SRM required longer computation time and handled the projection noise worse than the AE-SRM.Nevertheless, the MC-SRM inherently incorporates extensive modeling of the system and therefore experimental characterization was not required.

System Response Matrix Calculation Using Symmetries for Dual‐head PET Scanners

System Response Matrix Calculation Based on Distance-Driven Model and Solid Angle Model for Dual-Head PET System

Accurate Image Reconstruction with Computed System Response Matrix for a High-Sensitivity Dual-Head PET Scanner

The Dual Head Panel PET Image Reconstruction Based on Simulated System Response Matrix

Rapid Construction of System Response Matrix Based on Geometric Symmetries for the Quad-Head PET System

Image Reconstruction of a Dual-Head Small-Animal PET System by Using Monte-Carlo Computed System Response Matrix

Fast and Accurate Monte-Carlo Based System Response Modeling for A Digital Whole-Body Pet

Evaluation of 3D image reconstruction methods for a dual-head small-animal PET scanner

Performance Evaluation of a 90°-Rotating Dual-Head Small Animal PET System

An Effective Scatter Correction Method Based on Single Scatter Simulation for A 3d Whole-Body Pet Scanner

Use of Monte Carlo Simulations for the Scatter Events Analysis of PET Scanners

Comparison of GPU Reconstruction Based on Different Symmetries for Dual-Head PET.

An automatic algorithm to exploit the symmetries of the system response matrix in positron emission tomography iterative reconstruction

Derivation Of The System Matrix For An Animal Spect Scanner With Rotational Collimator And Stationary Ring Detector

Performance Evaluation of Biograph Pet/Ct System Based on Monte Carlo Simulation

Image Reconstruction with DOI Rebinning and PSF Modeling for the Quad-Head PET

Analytical, experimental, and Monte Carlo system response matrix for pinhole SPECT reconstruction

A PET System Design by Using Mixed Detectors: Resolution Properties

A Fast algorithm of PET System Response Matrix based on Straight Line Truncation

The Software System of a Dedicated Brain PET Scanner Using Dual-Ended Readout Detectors with High DOI Resolution

Accurate image reconstruction based on standard-Gaussian-model fitted system matrix in multipinhole small animal SPECT imaging