Abstract:Inferring the number of contributors (NoC) is a crucial step in interpreting DNA mixtures, as it directly affects the accuracy of the likelihood ratio calculation and the assessment of evidence strength. However, obtaining the correct NoC in complex DNA mixtures remains challenging due to the high degree of allele sharing and dropout. This study aimed to analyze the impact of allele sharing and dropout on NoC inference in complex DNA mixtures when using microhaplotypes (MH). The effectiveness and value of highly polymorphic MH for NoC inference in complex DNA mixtures were evaluated through comparing the performance of three NoC inference methods, including maximum allele count (MAC) method, maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) method, and random forest classification (RFC) algorithm. In this study, we selected the top 100 most polymorphic MH from the Southern Han Chinese (CHS) population, and simulated over 40 million complex DNA mixture profiles with the NoC ranging from 2 to 8. These profiles involve unrelated individuals (RM type) and related pairs of individuals, including parent-offspring pairs (PO type), full-sibling pairs (FS type), and second-degree kinship pairs (SE type). Our results indicated that how the number of detected alleles in DNA mixture profiles varied with the markers' polymorphism, kinship's involvement, NoC, and dropout settings. Across different types of DNA mixture, the MAC and MLE methods performed best in the RM type, followed by SE, FS, and PO types, while RFC models showed the best performance in the PO type, followed by RM, SE, and FS types. The recall (i.e., correct prediction rate) of all three methods for NoC inference were decreased as the NoC and dropout levels increased. Furthermore, the MLE method performed better at low NoC, whereas RFC models excelled at high NoC and/or high dropout levels, regardless of the availability of a priori information about related pairs of individuals in DNA mixtures. However, the RFC models which considered the aforementioned priori information and were trained specifically on each type of DNA mixture profiles, outperformed RFC_ALL model that did not consider such information. Finally, we provided recommendations for model building when applying machine learning algorithms to NoC inference.

Evaluating Mixed Stains with Contributors of Different Ethnic Groups under the NRC-II Recommendation 4.1.

The Evaluation of Mixed Stains from Different Ethnic Origins: General Result and Common Cases.

The statistical evaluation of DNA mixtures with contributors from different ethnic groups

Interpreting DNA mixtures with the presence of relatives

Interpreting Y-Chromosomal Dna Mixtures With The Presence Of Paternal Relatives And Contributors From Different Ethnic Groups

Interpreting forensic DNA mixtures: allowing for uncertainty in population substructure and dependence

Evaluating forensic DNA mixtures with contributors of different structured ethnic origins: a computer software

Evaluation of DNA mixtures involving two pairs of relatives

Interpreting DNA Mixtures with Related Contributors in Subdivided Populations

Complex DNA mixture analysis in a forensic context: evaluating the probative value using a likelihood ratio model

[Analysis and Discussion on Calculating Likelihood Ratio of DNA Mixture].

Evaluation of Large-Scale Highly Polymorphic Microhaplotypes in Complex DNA Mixtures Analysis Using RMNE Method.

Using simulated microhaplotype genotyping data to evaluate the value of machine learning algorithms for inferring DNA mixture contributor numbers

Evaluation of DNA Mixtures from Database Search.

Paternity testing and other inference about relationships from DNA mixtures

Non parametric Bayesian approach to LR assessment in case of rare haplotype match

Interpreting DNA mixtures with relatives of a missing suspect

FST estimates of 94 populations in China based on STR markers

The forensic DNA implications of genetic differentiation between endogamous communities.

Ethnic-Affiliation Estimation by Use of Population-Specific Dna Markers

Evidentiary evaluation of single cells renders highly informative forensic comparisons across multifarious admixtures