Abstract:<p>The objective of this study is to identify and explain the underlying patterns for rural collective action based on the practices of rural construction land consolidation (RCLC) in contemporary China. To that end, an analytical framework is developed to decompose rural collective action into diagnostic attributes, design attributes and outcomes. Then, an archetype analysis is performed, and a total of eight patterns regarding the collective action for RCLC are extracted from 30 first-hand cases in eastern, central and western China. These patterns jointly demonstrate that the alignment between the diagnostic attributes of rural construction land and rural households and the design attributes of institutional mechanisms contributes to the collective action for RCLC. The research findings corroborate the classic theoretical propositions of rural collective action, including small group size, coercive power, exclusive incentives and unequal interest. More importantly, several distinctive implications are drawn: 1) the sizes, locations and quality of rural construction land raise governance demand or create favorable conditions for rural collective action; 2) despite the small group size, the government and enterprises, as external actors, still engage in RCLC motivated by their political and economic goals in the transitional context of China, and they contribute to divergent pathways to rural collective action; 3) self-governance mechanisms consisting of community control, decision-making and coordination differ to prevent opportunistic behavior, mitigate conflicts of interest and reach consensus, depending on group sizes, whether RCLC is implemented within a village group or an administrative village as well as the extent to which the social capital accumulates in a rural community; 4) given the small group size but the large area of rural construction land involved, government participation or the formal and institutionalized self-governance mechanisms with powerful rural leadership can overcome "the tragedy of the anticommons". In general, this study provides new insights into land-related rural collective action and references for subsequent research on other types of rural collective action or in other transitional countries.</p>

"Qi" and the Reproduction of Collective Action in China’s Rural Areas

Easily Equalizing and Hardly Relieving under Collective Ownership of Rural Land:A special village case

"Field of Qi" and the Occurring Mechanism of Mass Disturbances:A comparative study of two cases

Everyday Strategies for Team Farming in Collective-Era China: Evidence from Qin Village

Shifting Boundaries Between the State and Society: Village Cadres As New Activists in Collective Petition

Rural revitalization, scholars, and the dynamics of the collective future in China

Study on the “Social-Psychological” Mechanism of Farmers from Environmental Resistance to Collective Silence

The Status of Collective Action among Rural Households in Underdeveloped Regions of China and Its Livelihood Effects under the Background of Rural Revitalization—Evidence from a Field Survey in Shanxi Province

Instrumental Civil Rights and Institutionalized Participation in China: A Case Study of Protest in Wukan Village

Ritualized Relational Work: Secret Banquets and Rural Cadres in China

The Application of Qiang Ethnic Culture in Strengthening the Consciousness of the Chinese National Community

Connecting Small Peasants with Large Markets: The Need for a New Type of Rural Collective Economy – a Case Study of Zhanqi Village

Patterns of rural collective action in contemporary China: An archetype analysis of rural construction land consolidation

The Reproduction of Power and Values of Social Action:A Case Study of the Director Election for the Xingfu Residential Community in a Northern City

Air Pollution and Grassroots Echoes of “ecological Civilization” in Rural China

Relational Repression in China: Using Social Ties to Demobilize Protesters

Peasants' Psychology And Rural Political Stability In China——A Framework And Its Application

Responsibility-driven Collective Action in the Context of Rapid Rural Depopulation

Informal Institutions, Collective Action, and Public Investment in Rural China

Do rural electoral institutions reflect public opinion in China? Evidence from village elections

Institutions and Work Incentives in Collective Farming in Maoist China