Observations on the Causes and Treatment of Chlorosis
R. Stockman
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.2.1824.1473
1895-12-14
British Medical Journal
Abstract:MANY causes of chlorosis are enumerated by authors, chief among them being absence of light and fresh air, overwork, especially under unfavourable conditions, heated rooms, insufficient exercise, depressing emotions and unhealthy excitement, indigestion, constipation, insufficient food, and excessive or otherwise faulty menstruation, besides others which need not be here particularised. Most of these are probably predisposing rather than direct causes, and I hope to show in this paper that there are two great and direct causative factors in chlorosis, namely, blood-loss and an insufficient supply of iron by the food. If this be correct, then excessive menstruation or other blood-loss and insufficient supply of food from any cause, are the only two factors among those just mentioned which directly bring on the anaemia, the others doing so only in as far as they contribute to produce these two. Virchow'a view that chlorosis is dependent on congenital hypoplasia of the arterial system is apparently contradicted by the fact that it is a condition which lasts at most for a few years. and often only for some weeks or months, being completely and permanently recovered from, azid hence the causes which produce it must also be transient and avoidable. It is possible, however, that such individuals may be congenitally deficient in blood-forming power, and thus readily tend to become anaemic when any strain is thrown on the blood. The theory supported by the late Sir Andrew Clark 1 and others, that chlorosis results from constipation, with consequent absorption of ptomaines which break down the red blood corpuscles. is in no way supported by facts but rather the contrary. Many cases of chlorosis do not suffer from constipation, and, surther, it has now been proved by trustworthy investigations that there is neither excessive formation of decomposition products in the intestinal canal, nor any excessive breaking down of the red corpuscles. As a matter of fact, fewer corpuscles break down in chlorosis than under normal conditions. The very pale colour of the urine, and frequently also of the fveces,2 indicates that less colouring matter than usual is being furnished by the haemoglobin, and hence that fewer red corpuscles are breaking down. When excessive decomposition is going on in the contents of the intestine, the products of this (compounds of skatol, phenol, etc.) become more abundant than usual in the urine, but Rethers3 and Morner 4 have found that in chlorosis these products are generally diminished in amount, thus conclusively proving that there is no excessive sepsis in the alimentary canal. These researches help further to disprove the truth of Hannon's and Bange's theory, which also rests on theassumption of increased intestinal decomposition, whereby the sulphuretted hydrogen and amnmonium sulphide supposed to be formed are said to separate the iron out of the food, and thus prevent its absorption. I have already shown,5 however, that both Sir Andrew Clark's and Bunge's theories are untenable on other grounds. It may now be held as proved, therefore, that in chlorosis there is no excessive breaking down of red corpuscles, and hence the anaemia must result either from deficient formation or excessive loss of blood. What elements in the blood are specially affected? The blood serum seems to be very little or not at all deteriorated, for L. Beale found6 the specific gravity and solids to be practically the same in a girl before treatment and after recovery, while Quinquaud7 found the 1 Lancet. ii, 1887, 1003. 2 VonNoorden, Berlin. klin. Wochenschr., 1895. 8 Di8sertation. Berlin, 1891. 4 Ztschr. f. physiol. Chemie, xviii, 1893. 5 BRITISH MBDICAL JOURNAL, 1893, i. 6 Med. Times, 1851, i, 618. Chimie Pathologique, 1880. solids to be 88 to 94 per 1,000 in chlorosis and 92 to 94 in health, the several constituents being practically unaltered. On the other hand the hwimoglobin is always deficient, and the number of red blood corpuscles is usually, but not invariably, so. In 63 cases of chlorosis which 1 have treated in hospital,8 the lowest estimate of hbemoglobin (on Gowers's hiemoglobinometer) was 20 per cent., the highest 66 per cent., while only 6 of these cases had over 4million corpuscles per cubic millimetre, the others having from 4down to slightly under 2 millions. Not only are the corpuscles deficient always in haemoglobin and usually in number, but often many of them are ill-formed and small. The haemoglobin, however, is invariably deficient whether the corpuscles be so or not, and the severity of the clinical symptoms depends chiefly on the extent of this diminution in hiemoglobin. Quinquaud found that in healthy women 100 e.cm. blood yielded 21 to 24 c.cm. oxygen, while in chlorotics the same amount of blood gave only 10 to 15 c.cm. It is the deficiency of haemoglobin combined with the consequent deficiency of oxygen which gives rise to the pallor, debility, breathlessness, and impairment of functions generally which all go to form the clinical picture of chlorosis. In discussing the etiology of chlorotic anaemia, as it is found in young girls at or not very long past the age of puberty, the chief points which attract attention are the sex, age, the condition of the digestive organs, the condition of the menstrual functions, and the frequent tendency to relapse. I shall consider these in the order named. Se'x.-Chlorosis is infinitely most frequent in very young women, and this suggests the question as to what iDfluence sex exercises on the composition of the blood. Women generally in health have about 10 per cent. fewer corpuscles than men, 8 to 10 per cent. less heemoglobin, and 4 or 5 per cent. more water in the blood. Their blood is therefore less able to withstand any drain on it, and, as will be more particularly noticed immediately, it is well recognised that at puberty and for some time after, there is a greater drain than takes place in lads at the same age. Age.-Leichtenstern9 found that from 18 to 25 the haemoglobin is about 8 per cent. less than from 25 to 45 years of age, and Sorensen that from 15 to 28 in healthy women the number of corpuscles is less than at other ages, which he attributes to menstruation. Further, girls develop with extreme rapidity from 15 to 18, throwing a great strain on the organism, which suffers in various ways besides in blood forming. Out of my 63 cases of chlorosis previously cited no fewer than 41 were between the ages of 15 and 20, and the highest age at which a first attack occurred was 23. Owing to the strain of rapid growth at this age all the various functions of the body suffer, and not only is blood formation deficient in itself, but digestion is impaired and appetite poor,