Application of spatial filtering model based on different spatial weight settings in hand-foot-mouth disease incidence data
CHEN Xi,LI Ke,YIN Yun,LIU Yuanhua,HONG Jie,SHI Jin,HUANG Jiaqi,ZHAO Zheng,XU Jiayao,YUAN Rui,ZHANG Zhijie
DOI: https://doi.org/10.16462/j.cnki.zhjbkz.2023.11.004
2023-01-01
Abstract:Objective To study the application of spatial filtering model in the incidence data of hand-foot-mouth disease(HFMD)in East China given different spatial weight,and to determine its applicability by comparing the effects of different spatial models.Methods The incidence data of hand,foot and mouth disease in East China in 2009 were collected and the related influencing factors were identified.Four different spatial weight matrices were decomposed using the eigenvector spatial filtering method(ESF),and the eigenvectors were determined according to Moran's I(MI)value and stepwise regression,which was introduced as the spatial filter into the model.The effects of different weight matrices were compared by Akaike information criterion(AIC),deviance information criterion(DIC)and Root Mean Square Error(RMSE).Finally,the spatial filtering model based on the optimal weight matrix was compared with the Bayesian spatial model in terms of the fitting value,standard deviation and confidence interval of the model coefficients.Results There were a total of 403 607 HFMD cases reported in East China in 2009,most of which concentrated in the west of Shandong Province and the southeast of Zhejiang Province.According to MI test,HFMD exhibited spatial correlation in East China.After the spatial filter was introduced into the normal negative binomial distribution model,the residual of the spatial filter model ceased to show spatial autocorrelation(MI were-0.11,-0.15,-0.08 and-0.09,respectively,all P＞0.05),and the spatial autocorrelation was efectively removed.The Rook weight matrix was considered the optimal weight matrix.Although,the regression coefficient of the spatial filtering model under the optimal weight matrix were comparable to that of the Bayesian spatial model,the spatial filtering model was still significantly outweighed by the Bayesian spatial model in terms of standard deviation and confidence interval.Conclusions The spatial filtering model demonstrates the advantages of simple calculation and accurate results.Therefore,it can be applied to visualize the map patterns at different geographic scales from whole to local,and to reveal the underlying spatial structure of disease onset.It is also applicable as an effective alternative to traditional complex spatial models.