The Status of the Nonresponding Hand Affect Simon Effect in the Go/No-Go Task

Wang Li,Zhang Liwen,Zhang Mingliang,Chen Antao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.16719/j.cnki.1671-6981.2013.01.022
2013-01-01
Abstract:The Simon effect arises if a spatial response feature is used to represent one or more responses in working memory.Previous studies have found that the go/no - go task,in which stimuli are the same as the standard Simon task,generates the Simon effect only when the participants use the spatial feature to represent response by referring to the location of the nonresponding hand.However,the participants can select flexibly the reference frame for action according to sensory context Further,the reference frame determines whether spatial anatomical code or the cognitive spatial code is used to represent the one response in the go/no - go task.Thus,we believe that sensory context of the nonresponding hand may affect the nature of the Simon effect in the go/no - go task.If the spatial anatomical code is used to represent the response,then the visuomotor Simon effect may arise;if the cognitive spatial code is used,then the cognitive Simon effect may arise. To explore the hypothesis,we implemented three experiments.In the experiments,the stimuli were red or green squares presented in left or right physical locations.Participants were instructed to perform a spatial response to one color and refrain from responding to another color.But the status of the nonresponding hand were different.Specifically,in Experiment 1,the participants were only required to press one key by index finger of one hand and put the nonresponding hand on any place except the desk and keyboard;in Experiment 2,the participants were asked to put their nonresponding hand on a fixed location of the desktop;in Experiment 3,the participants were instructed to put their nonresponding hand on a fixed key(e.g.,if the response key was "Z" then put the nonresponding hand on "/",and vice versa).Moreover,if the Simon effects was obtained in the experiments,we would further explore the different mechanism of Simon effect with reaction time(RT) distribution analysis.To that end,the correct RTs of each participant were vincentized in separate experimental condition(i.e.,rank - ordered RTs were divided into equally sized quantiles,and the mean RTs were grouped into equally spaced quantiles). The results showed that in Experiment 1,the Simon effect was not obtained,F(1,21) =.39,p =.54,while it was obtained in Experiment 2(F(1,20) =8.48,p<.01) and in Experiment 3(F(1,25) = 10.93,p <.01).Moreover,the RT distribution analysis showed that the size of Simon effect in Experiment 2 was rather stable from the first to fourth quantile but disappeared in the fifth quantile,and it increased from the first to the fifth quantile in Experiment 3.The results demonstrate that representing the response by the spatial feature is the prerequisite for the generation of the Simon effect.Moreover,the results implied that the nature of the Simon effect relies on the sensory context of the nonresponding hand.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?