Abstract:For the Z-R relationship in radar-based rainfall estimation, the distribution of corresponding R values for a given Z value (or the corresponding Z value for a given R value) may be highly skewed. However, the traditional power-law model is physically deduced and fitted under the normal-distribution presumption of radar wave echoes associated with a rain rate value, and it may not be very appropriate. Considering this problem, the authors devised several generalized linear models with different forms and distribution presumptions to represent the Z-R relationship. Radar-reflectivity scans observed by a CINRAD/SC Doppler radar and 5-minute rainfall accumulation recorded by 10 ground gauges were used to fit these models. All data used in this study were collected during some large rainfalls of the period from 2005 to 2007. The radar and all gauges were installed in the catchment of the Yishu River, a branch of the Huaihe River in China. Three models based on normal distribution and a dBZ presumption of gamma distribution were fitted using maximum-likelihood techniques, which were resolved by genetic algorithms. Comparisons of estimated maximized likelihoods based on assumptions of gamma and normal distribution showed that all generalized linear models (GLMs) of presumed gamma distribution were better fitted than GLMs based on normal distribution. In a comparison of maximum-likelihood, the differences between these three models were small. Three error statistics were used to assess the agreement between radar estimated rainfall and gauge rainfall: relative bias (B), root mean square error (RMSE), and correlation coefficient (r). The results showed that no one model was excellent in all criteria. On the whole, the GLM-based models gave smaller relative bias than the traditional power-law model. It is suggested that validations conducted in many previous works should have been made against a specific criterion but overlooked others.

A Probability-Distribution Model for Rain Rate

Impact Analysis for Rainfall Depthsimulation of Different Durations Through Several Copulas

Analysis of the Inhomogeneity and Randomness of Rainfalls Based on the Double-rectangle Shaped Hyetograph

Stochastic Generation of Daily Rainfall Events: A Single-Site Rainfall Model with Copula-based Joint Simulation of Rainfall Characteristics and Classification and Simulation of Rainfall Patterns

Modelling rainfall in selected agricultural hubs in Nigeria: a comparative probability distributions study

Stochastic Theory of the Size Distribution of Raindrops

Rainfall frequency analysis using event-maximum rainfalls – An event-based mixture distribution modeling approach

A probabilistic description of rain storms incorporating peak intensities

Analysis of Probability Distributions for Modelling Extreme Rainfall Events and Detecting Climate Change: Insights from Mathematical and Statistical Methods

A New Probability Distribution Model of Turbulent Irradiance Based on Born Perturbation Theory

Multimodel Response Assessment for Monthly Rainfall Distribution in Some Selected Indian Cities Using Best Fit Probability as a Tool

On the asymptotic approximation to the probability distribution of extremal precipitation

Improved mathematical models of statistical regularities in precipitation

Extreme event statistics of daily rainfall: dynamical systems approach

A Censored Bayesian Hierarchical Model For Precipitation

A new extension of XLindley distribution with mathematical properties, estimation, and application on the rainfall data

A Comparison of Four Precipitation Distribution Models Used in Daily Stochastic Models

Stochastic daily rainfall generation on tropical islands with complex topography

Probability Analysis of Annual and Monthly Rainfall in Mizoram, India: Evaluating Goodness of Fit and Identifying Best Probability Distributions

ENTROPY THEORY AND PARAMETERIZATION OF NONUNIFORM DISTRIBUTION OF PRECIPITATION

A Comparison of Several 5-Minute Radar-Rainfall Estimation Models