Negative Helical CT Cholangiopancreatography Compared with Direct Cholangiopancreatography
张追阳,丁乙,倪才方,龚镭
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/j.issn:1005-1201.2002.07.009
2002-01-01
Abstract:Objective To further evaluate the clinical value of negative helical CT cholangiopancreatography (N CTCP) in patients with extrahepatic bile duct obstructive diseases Methods The helical CT with intravenous contrast media was performed in 33 patients with bile duct obstructive diseases and direct cholangiopancreatography was conducted within 48 hrs after CT scanning (13 cases with PTC and 20 cases with ERCP) The raw data were reconstructed into axial source images (ASI), which were edited on workstations and then minimum intensity projection (MinIP) was applied to yield N CTCP MinIP images were compared with direct cholangiopancreatography in visualizing on bile duct grades and visibility of pancreatic duct (PD), gallbladder (GB), cystic duct (CyD), and as well as identifying obstructive location and nature Results There were significant differences between N CTCP and PTC or ERCP in visualizing the bile duct grades ( T -=1 5, T += 19 5, P 0 05; T -=3 5, T +=87 5, P 0 01, respectively) Although N CTCP had a relatively lower visibility of CyD, it could both visualize much more segments of the biliary tree and had higher visibility of GB and PD than those of ERCP, PTC, respectively In 33 cases, N CTCP in determining obstructive location and nature (including sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy) was 100 0%, 87 5%, 77 8%, and 84 8%, respectively On the contrast, those parameters of the direct cholangiopancreatography were 90 9%, 66 7%, 100 0%, and 75 8%, respectively There were no significant differences between two procedures (χ 2=1 33, P 0 05; χ 2=2 29, P 0 05; χ 2=0 00, P 0 05; χ 2=0 44, P 0 05) Conclusion N CTCP had a better visualization of the whole biliary tree than PTC or ERCP in patients with obstructive biliary diseases, and had similar results in identifying obstructive location and nature with that of the direct cholangiopancreatography As one of the noninvasive techniques, N CTCP provided another way to diagnose extrahepatic bile obstructive diseases and was an effective alternative to unsuccessful direct cholangiopancreatography or for those patients who were unsuitable for the direct cholangiopancreatography