A Comparative study on the clinical application of Modified Checklist for Autism in Toddlers(M-CHAT) and Checklist for Autism in Toddlers(CHAT)
SHEN Ji-Ying,XIAO Ting,XIAO Xiang,XIAO Zhou,ZOU Bing,LIANG Feng-Jing,QIU Ting,WANG Chen-Yang,WANG Min-Jie,KE Xiao-Yan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-6729.2012.05.005
2012-01-01
Abstract:Objective: To compare the application of Modified Checklist for Autism in Toddlers(M-CHAT) and that of Checklist for Autism in Toddlers(CHAT) in the clinical screening.Methods: Sixty-nine children with pervasive developmental disorders(PDDs) according to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-Ⅳ(DSM-Ⅳ-TR)criterion and 32 age-and gender-matched children with other developmental disorder were included.All subjects were evaluated with M-CHAT and CHAT.Results: The sensitivity of M-CHAT was higher than that of CHAT(0.99 vs.0.81,P<0.01),the specificity was lower(0.16 vs.0.51,P<0.01),and there was significant difference between CHAT and M-CHAT in screening results [(95/6)vs.(72/29),P<0.05].In the children younger than 24 months,both the positive screening result of M-CHAT(17/0) and that of CHAT(15/2) were consistent with the clinical diagnosis(12/5),and the children older than 36 months,both the positive screening result of M-CHAT(6/1)and that of CHAT(3/4) were consistent with the clinical diagnosis(6/1),the concordance rate was 0.71(P>0.05),and no significant difference between the positive screening result of M-CHAT and that of CHAT(P>0.05);but in the children aged 24-36 months,there was significant difference between the positive screening result of M-CHAT and the gold standard [(72/5) vs.(51/26),P<0.05],and there was also significant difference between the positive screening result of M-CHAT and that of CHAT [(72/5) vs.(54/23),P<0.05],but no significant difference between the clinical diagnosis and CHAT,and the concordance rate was 0.73(P>0.05).Conclusion: It suggests that the sensitivity of M-CHAT is higher than that of CHAT,and it is a promising screening instrument for PDDs in normal toddlers.Applying in the clinic of child developmental disorder,the screening results of CHAT are consistent with clinical diagnosis.