Abstract:Two of the fundamental no-go theorems of quantum information are the no-cloning theorem (that it is impossible to make copies of general quantum states) and the no-teleportation theorem (the prohibition on telegraphing, or sending quantum states over classical channels without pre-shared entanglement). They are known to be equivalent, in the sense that a collection of quantum states is telegraphable if and only if it is clonable. Our main result suggests that this is not the case when computational efficiency is considered. We give a collection of quantum states and quantum oracles relative to which these states are efficiently clonable but not efficiently telegraphable. Given that the opposite scenario is impossible (states that can be telegraphed can always trivially be cloned), this gives the most complete quantum oracle separation possible between these two important no-go properties. We additionally study the complexity class clonableQMA, a subset of QMA whose witnesses are efficiently clonable. As a consequence of our main result, we give a quantum oracle separation between clonableQMA and the class QCMA, whose witnesses are restricted to classical strings. We also propose a candidate oracle-free promise problem separating these classes. We finally demonstrate an application of clonable-but-not-telegraphable states to cryptography, by showing how such states can be used to protect against key exfiltration.

Quantum Information Cannot Be Split into Complementary Parts

Quantum Information Splitting Using Cluster State

Information Complementarity: A New Paradigm for Decoding Quantum Incompatibility

Nonexistence of a Universal Quantum Machine to Examine the Precision of Unknown Quantum States

Quantum Information and Wave function Collapse

Universal and Original-Preserving Quantum Copying is Impossible

A Computational Separation Between Quantum No-cloning and No-telegraphing

Quantum Nonlocality and Applications in Quantum-Information Processing of Hybrid Entangled States

Algorithmic No-Cloning Theorem

The Information-Complete Quantum Theory

Entropic Quantum Central Limit Theorem and Quantum Inverse Sumset Theorem

Quantum chi-squared tomography and mutual information testing

Quantum Zero-Error Algorithms Cannot be Composed

Condition and Capability of Quantum State Separation

Non-compression of Quantum Phase Information

IMPOSSIBILITY OF PERFECT QUANTUM SEALING OF CLASSICAL INFORMATION

Linearly-Independent Quantum States Can Be Cloned by A Unitary-Reduction Operation

Quantum catalysis of information

Quantum separability, time reversal and canonical decompositions

Splitting Unknown Qubit State Using Five-Qubit Entangled State

Optimal Compression for Identically Prepared Qubit States