An Analysis of Policymaking Process of Provincial Environmental Policy:Case Study of the Ecological Compensation Policy for Conservation of Water and Soil in Shannxi and Yunnan

WU Liang,MA Li QI Ye,QI Ye

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-2104.2012.03.015

2012-01-01

Abstract:More and more environmental policies have been established by provincial governments in China in recent years.When confronted with various problems,how can policymakers of provincial governments realize the relevance,significance and urgency of an environmental problem and approve a policy? What are the characteristics of the policymaking process of a provincial environmental policy compared with an economic policy? This paper focuses on two case studies to answer these questions.One is the ecological compensation policy for conservation of water and soil established by the government of Shaanxi province.The other one is a similar policy which is being established by the government of Yunnan province.The two cases demonstrate that policy entrepreneur in the policymaking process is head of the administrative department in charge of the problem,not the leader of the provincial government.The approach adopted by the administrative department to establish the policy is to persuade the leaders of the provincial government to approve the policy.In order to persuade the policymakers,the administrative department forms an advocate coalition which includes other departments of the provincial government and related stakeholders,and also conducts scientific research to summarize the relevance,significance and urgency of the problem and provides a policy draft based on scientific and legislative evidence.The policymaking process of an environmental policy in the provincial government is different from the corresponding process in the central government.It is also different from the policymaking process of economic policies in provincial governments.