Different anesthetic methods for decreasing gynecological surgical trauma responses: A prospective randomized controlled trial

Yu Chen,Yang Baxian

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1009-6604.2007.04.013

2007-01-01

Abstract:Objective To investigate anesthetic methodology for decreasing surgical trauma responses in gynecological operations.Methods A prospective randomized controlled trial was carried out.The study was approved by the Ethics Committee of Peking University Health Science Center(Warrant No:0536).A written informed consent was obtained from each patient and his/her relatives.A total of 48 ASA Ⅰ～Ⅱ patients scheduled for selective gynecological surgery was enrolled in this study.They were randomly divided into four groups with 12 patients in each group:the Group A undergoing combined spinal and epidural anesthesia(CSEA)with target controlled infusion of midazolam for sedation;the Group B undergoing CSEA with intravenous bolus of midazolam for sedation;the Group C receiving CSEA;and the Group D,CSEA combined with general anesthesia.Blood pressure,heart rate,oxygen saturation(SpO2),bispectral index(BIS),and serum levels of cortisol and IL-6,as well as anesthetic responses,were monitored and compared among the four groups.Results The Group A had a moderate sedation degree(OAA/S:degree 3～4;BIS value:75～85).No respiratory inhibition was noted in this group.Before operation,levels of serum cortisol had no statistical differences between every two groups.The ratio of cortisol changes(end-operation value minus preoperative value)to preoperative value in the Group A was 0.43±0.18,significantly lower than that in the Group C(0.65±014;q=4.061,P<0.05).Intraoperative tension discomfort happened in 1 patient in the Group A,significantly fewer than in the Group C(7 patients,P=0.027).Patients in the Group B were relatively deeply sedated,and many of them reached OAA/S degree 2.Transient respiratory inhibition happened in 9 patients in this group.The ratio of cortisol changes to preoperative cortisol value in the Group B was 0.62±0.23,significantly higher than that in the Group A(0.43±0.18;q=3.508,P<0.05).Significantly more patients were bothered with tension discomfort in the Group C than in the Group A(P=0.027)and the Group D(P=0.005).Among the four groups,the most significant change was observed in the Group C on the ratio of cortisol changes to preoperative cortisol value(0.65±0.14).There was no statistically significant difference on the ratio between the Group D and the Group A(q=1.056,P>0.05)or Group C(q=2.816,P>0.05).Conclusions Combined spinal and epidural anesthesia combined with target controlled infusion of midazolam has slight side effects and serum cortisol changes,suitable for gynecological operations.