Measuring the ecological impact of tourist wastes:methodology and cases study of Jiuzhaigou and Huangshan National Park

ZHANG Jin-He

2008-01-01

Acta Ecologica Sinica

Abstract:Ecological impact assessment of tourism is basis for enacting and implementing a series of principles, policies, laws and measures for environmental protection. This paper gives the definition of tourist wastes from the characters of tourism ecosystem cycle of substances and energy. Based on the theory and method of ecological footprint, the paper puts forward the ecological impact measuring model of tourist waste and takes the Jiuzhaigou and Huangshan national park for examples, calculates and analyses the ecological impact index and its internal and external ecological impact on Jiuzhaigou and Huangshan National Park in 2004. Seven characteristics have been summarized: (1) The total tourist waste ecological footprint of Jiuzhaigou National Park reaches to 46960.5678hm2 in 2004, which is 2.1 times of Huangshan′s 22331.4490hm2 in 2004. The per capita tourist waste ecological footprint is 0.024560966hm2 of Jiuzhaigou in 2004, 1.76 times of Huangshan′s 0.01394088 hm2. (2) The ecological footprint of apparent ecological factors is very small. Ecological footprint of all waste water, human dejection, solid rubbish, waste treatment facilities amount to only 0.16 percent of total tourist waste ecological footprint in Jiuzhaigou, and 0.3 percent in Huangshan. However, the ecological footprint of recessive ecological factors is very big, the ecological footprint of CO2 emission is 99.84 percent of the total tourist waste ecological footprint in Jiuzhaigou and 99.70 percent in Huangshan. (3) The total amount of CO2 emission by tourism development is 309455.66t in Jiuzhaigou and 146947.84t in Huangshan. The per capita CO2 emission by tourism is 161.85kg in Jiuzhaigou and 91.74kg in Huangshan. This indicates that tourism development has high ecological impact on global climate change. Air travel needs to be seen as the most problematic global environmental impact of tourism, which has about 40 percent of total amount of CO2 emission by tourism development in Jiuzhaigou and Huangshan.(4) A comparison of the ecological footprint of tourist, local residents and tourism correlation industries shows that tourism correlation industries(transport, accommodation) have the most ecological footprint about 98.74 percent of total, whereas it is about 1 percent for tourists and 0.26 percent for local residents. (5) Our analysis reveals that tourist wastes have different ecological impact between internal and external regions of tourist destination. Among the total tourist waste ecological footprint of Jiuzhaigou, there has only 1.26% impact for Jiuzhaigou National Park itself, while 34.8% for the region on the way from Jiuzhaigou to Chengdu City 、63.94% for the region out of Chengdu City. As for Huangshan, there has only 14.6% impact for Huangshan National Park itself, while 31.97% for the region of Huangshan City 、53.43% for the region out of Huangshan City. (6) Eco-efficiency of tourism for Jiuzhaigou National Park is 2.53kgCO2-e/US$, while for Huangshan National Park, it is 1.67kgCO2-e/US$. (7) Due to the differences among scale, character, source of tourist market and mode of transport, the tourist waste has different ecological impact on different tourist destination. In generally, reducing the number of tourist, shortening travel distances, avoiding traveling by air are key to reducing the ecological impacts of tourist waste and the most important precondition for tourism sustainability.