When is Psychological Safety Helpful in Organizations? A Longitudinal Study
Monica C. Higgins,Shoshana R. Dobrow,Jennie Miles Weiner,Haiyang Liu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5465/amd.2018.0242
2020-01-01
Academy of Management Discoveries
Abstract:Research has documented many benefits associated with team-level psychological safety. However, we know little about the boundary conditions of psychological safety, such as how it operates at the organization level and if and when it is helpful over time. In this research, we explore how organization-level psychological safety, in conjunction with another aspect of workplace climate, felt accountability, impacts organizational performance over time. Our study context is the New York City public school system, a context rife with uncertainty and calls for change, including pressure on teachers to produce and improve student outcomes. Utilizing over 170,000 survey responses from teachers in 545 schools across three years, our multilevel analyses unexpectedly show that psychological safety is not on its own, nor necessarily, "helpful" with regard to organizational performance over time. Indeed, the best conditions for fostering organizational performance occur when psychological safety is relatively low and felt accountability is relatively high. Thus, these two dimensions of workplace climate appear to be interrelated in critical ways over time, albeit unexpectedly. We conclude with implications of our discoveries for future research, and propose new lines of research on the roles of interdependence, attention, and time for studying psychological safety at the organization level.