Effects Of Fentanyl And Butorphanol On Uterine Contraction Pain After Induced Abortion: A Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial
Changting Yan,Na Ding,Yunhua Wei,Zhen Yuan,Yuhua Li,Yu Cao,Qun Wang,Xueya Yao,Peng Huang
2018-01-01
Abstract:Objective: Surgical induced abortion is a common remedy for contraceptive failure, usually processed under intravenous anesthesia in a clinic. Uterine contraction pain often occurs after the operation, affecting recovery or inducing more severe complications in women. Methods: To relieve this kind of pain, this study performed a randomized controlled trial using common analgesics, including fentanyl and butorphanol, from January to December in 2016. Ninety-nine patients meeting the inclusion criteria were included in the study and randomly divided into three groups: propofol group, fentanyl group, and butorphanol group. In the propofol group, patients were anesthetized with a single use of propofol. In the fentanyl group and butorphanol group, a combination of fentanyl and propofol was administered. Basic information, evaluation of anesthesia effects, changes of vital signs, incidence of complications, and Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) scores for uterine contraction pain were collected and analyzed. Results: Butorphanol and fentanyl groups demonstrated superior anesthetic effects over the propofol group (P<0.001), but no significant differences were found between the former two groups (P=0.064). Butorphanol group consumed the least propofol, compared to the other two groups (115.91 +/- 21.70 mg, P<0.01), and recovery time (14.00 +/- 1.35 min) was a bit longer than the fentanyl group (P=0.0015) and propofol group (12.61 +/- 1.91, P=0.2416), although the latter difference was not significant. Hypotension in the fentanyl group was obvious and incidence (48.5%) was higher than in propofol (P=0.009) and butorphanol groups (30.3%, P=0.131). Incidence of dizziness was also higher in fentanyl group, compared with the other two groups (P=0.007), while drowsiness occurred most frequently in the butorphanol group (P=0.000). Changes in vital signs were maximal in fentanyl group and minimal in the propofol group. Uterine contraction pain after surgery was most severe in propofol group (P=0.003) and slightest in the butorphanol group (P<0.01) when discharged. Conclusion: This present study provides evidence for selecting proper analgesics in induced abortion. Butorphanol is more suitable for stabilizing vital signs and preventing uterine contraction pain than fentanyl, during and after the operation.