Abstract:Background: Given the health and welfare impacts of haze, haze reduction governance challenges Chinese policy-makers. Surprisingly, there have been no studies of the differences in the public's willingness to pay (WTP) for haze governance within a province. Yet haze reduction policies are implemented at the provincial level. Based on the contingent valuation method, data on WTP for haze governance across four industrial cities in Shandong province were collected using a questionnaire survey. Method: A combination of stratified sampling and non-probability sampling methods were used, yielding a valid sample of 1006 respondents. The Heckman sample selection model was used to analyze factors determining WTP and WTP amount. Results: 53% of respondents were unwilling to pay for haze reduction, while less than 1% of these respondents were satisfied with Shandong's air quality. About half (47%) of the respondents were willing to pay, on average, US$14.14 per household per year for haze governance. We found that there were significant inter-city differences in the WTP and WTP amounts: those with a higher income, education, haze knowledge, and haze concern were WTP; age, marital status, and subjective indicators displayed a negative relationship with WTP amount. About two thirds of the non-payers, and those with poor environmental knowledge, argued that air quality improvement was mainly the responsibility of governments (39.3%) and polluters (25.6%), instead of ordinary citizens. Further, 27% of non-payers said that their income was too low to contribute to a pollution tax and 6.3% claimed that they did not believe the funds would be used effectively for environmental conservation. Conclusions: City-specific differences in WTP may caution against "one size fits all" policies. The study indicates that the government may need to target policies to specific cities and the characteristics of residents in those cities by age, education, and income groups and residents' subjective evaluation of the government and the haze problem and those responsible for pollution.

Analysis of Urban Residents' Willingness to Pay for Improving Air Quality in Typical Cities in Shandong Province

Analysis of Residents’ Willingness to Pay for Air Pollution Related Diseases in Qingdao

Study on Residents' Willingness to Pay for Improving Air Quality in Beijing

Analysis of Residents' Willingness to Pay to Reduce Air Pollution to Improve Children's Health in Community and Hospital Settings in Shanghai, China

Air Quality Improvement Estimation and Assessment Using Contingent Valuation Method, A Case Study in Beijing

Public willingness to pay for urban smog mitigation and its determinants: A case study of Beijing, China

Haze Attitudes and the Willingness to Pay for Haze Improvement: Evidence from Four Cities in Shandong Province, China

Analysis to the factors of willingness to pay for the air pollution in Lanzhou City

The Public Perceptions and Willingness to Pay: from the Perspective of the Smog Crisis in China

Exploring the Spatial Heterogeneity of Residents' Marginal Willingness to Pay for Clean Air in Shanghai

Application of Contingent Valuation Method in Valuing Health Gains from Air Quality Improvement

Willingness to Pay to Reduce Health Risks Related to Air Quality: Evidence from a Choice Experiment Survey in Beijing

Willingness to Pay for Environmental Protection in China: Air Pollution, Perception, and Government Involvement

Willingness to Pay of Urban and Suburban Households in Beijing for an Ecological Project in the Surrounding Areas

Influential factors of public intention to improve the air quality in China

Evaluating Willingness to Pay for the Temporal Distribution of Different Air Quality Improvements: is China's Clean Air Target Adequate to Ensure Welfare Maximization?

How Much Will the Chinese Public Pay for Air Pollution Mitigation? A Nationwide Empirical Study Based on a Willingness-to-pay Scenario and Air Purifier Costs

Social Acceptance Towards the Air Pollution in China: Evidence from Public's Willingness to Pay for Smog Mitigation

Urban Households' Location Preference: the Estimation of Willingness-To-Pay Grapient Model

Residents' Willingness to Pay for Water Pollution Treatment and Its Influencing Factors: a Case Study of Taihu Lake Basin

Propensity to Migrate and Willingness to Pay Related to Air Pollution among Different Populations in Wuhan, China